Comment 'Cawkazn [QUOTE]but ...' to 'ultimate survival dog'

  • Cawkazn [QUOTE]but one thing i think of in a doomsday scenario is really how much protection can a dog offer? [/QUOTE] This is my line of thought too. To me there's really two possibilities- either you don't need protection, or you do, and therefore a protection dog is useless. To me if it's a dangerous threatening environment then the unit, the duo, has to together be like a wary cautious, frankly fearful, wild animal. Evading altercations as much as possible, bluffing aggression to avoid fights when necessary. Actually engaging in fights such an extreme last resort that committing pretty much any of your dog to that is simply a waste of adaptations that could be going in another more useful direction. Even if you did have a dog fully committed in design to kicking ass at physical altercations it would either prove unnecessary (most of the time) or not good enough (on the rare occassion a serious threat presented itself and persisted). You'd be better off evading that threat with your alert yapping smart cautious and quick dog. It just seems strange to be sitting around with this big beastly defense - oriented dog waiting for this worse case scenario that probably won't happen, and if it does your dog won't be much use anyway, while all this time you could have a dog that actually is helping you all day, and then is also perfectly capable of being an alarm and harassing distraction should a threat arise, which really is more appropriate to deal with a threat in survival conditions than an "engaging warrior" anyway. I want an engaging badass gripping dog in this fantasy hypothetical, it just unfortunately doesn't make sense IMO. I think a guard dog that attacks threats is a luxury suited to modern civilisation. Society takes care of all the "survival" so that specialisation in this particular, rather obscure, little department is feasible and even desirable. In a wild survival scenario there are just way more important things to worry about than nobley engaging threats in that particular "cool" ego-fluffing way so they get their butts kicked and learn a lesson or whatever. It's time to be smart and walk away from such situations, you've got struggling to survive to worry about. There's a reason wild animals are, for lack of a better word, cowards as a general rule. It makes sense. It's practical to swallow your pride if you're going to want to be successful surviving in the wilderness. I'd want my dog to be brave and loyal, in defending me, but smart. I don't want it fighting bears or zombies or scumbag opportunist criminals even. It can alert me to their presence, annoy and harass and distract them yes. But fight them? In no way is that desirable, and on top of that there's just the rest of the time when I'd like my dog to be suited to catching me food, which unfortunately will imply sacrificing an aptitude for close quarter combat. But it's totally worth the sacrifice, it's an easy choice to make. I can easily accept me and my dog will have to slink off when a grizzly bear or gang of mad-maxesque baddies comes into our area. It will be an inconvenience but a reasonable one. Then we can go catch fast game consistently and thrive somewhere else. Conversely I try to imagine going the bad ass protection dog route. Ok so we sit around with the dog whining at me cause it's hungry and I'm like "yeah I bet you are hungry you needlessly big fat oaf, me too" and then the gang of mad max guys come and my cool dog runs over and chews on one while the others lash it to death with big chains, and I'm like "well what the hell was the point of that?". Replace the mad max guys with a bear, and even replace the dog with a sensible LGD that smartly wards it off, that's a little better but still the celebration will be short-lived cause we'll just go back to sitting around looking at eachother and being hungry. I could have had some collie/grey lurcher with me that just distracted and annoyed the bear while I slunk away, then caught up and helped me catch 5 rabbits in 2 hours that I could stew in a pot while I used my free time to build a new shelter. I really think I'm just being practical.