• 775

ultimate survival dog

My vote I think would be for the Alaskan Malamute. They can tolerate freezing weather, their good and smart hunters and will put a bear on bay but without mindlessly attacking it head first and getting themselves killed. They are also big enough to keep many wild animals away. They lack energy in hot weather though.

Replies (132)

    • [quote1332759370=Astibus] [quote1332733682=LeeRobinson] She is one of my favorite up and comers at this time. (Pictured below at 21 months... [/quote1332733682] Lemme guess, she's up for breeding? [/quote1332759370] Not yet.
      • Cawkazn [QUOTE]but one thing i think of in a doomsday scenario is really how much protection can a dog offer? [/QUOTE] This is my line of thought too. To me there's really two possibilities- either you don't need protection, or you do, and therefore a protection dog is useless. To me if it's a dangerous threatening environment then the unit, the duo, has to together be like a wary cautious, frankly fearful, wild animal. Evading altercations as much as possible, bluffing aggression to avoid fights when necessary. Actually engaging in fights such an extreme last resort that committing pretty much any of your dog to that is simply a waste of adaptations that could be going in another more useful direction. Even if you did have a dog fully committed in design to kicking ass at physical altercations it would either prove unnecessary (most of the time) or not good enough (on the rare occassion a serious threat presented itself and persisted). You'd be better off evading that threat with your alert yapping smart cautious and quick dog. It just seems strange to be sitting around with this big beastly defense - oriented dog waiting for this worse case scenario that probably won't happen, and if it does your dog won't be much use anyway, while all this time you could have a dog that actually is helping you all day, and then is also perfectly capable of being an alarm and harassing distraction should a threat arise, which really is more appropriate to deal with a threat in survival conditions than an "engaging warrior" anyway. I want an engaging badass gripping dog in this fantasy hypothetical, it just unfortunately doesn't make sense IMO. I think a guard dog that attacks threats is a luxury suited to modern civilisation. Society takes care of all the "survival" so that specialisation in this particular, rather obscure, little department is feasible and even desirable. In a wild survival scenario there are just way more important things to worry about than nobley engaging threats in that particular "cool" ego-fluffing way so they get their butts kicked and learn a lesson or whatever. It's time to be smart and walk away from such situations, you've got struggling to survive to worry about. There's a reason wild animals are, for lack of a better word, cowards as a general rule. It makes sense. It's practical to swallow your pride if you're going to want to be successful surviving in the wilderness. I'd want my dog to be brave and loyal, in defending me, but smart. I don't want it fighting bears or zombies or scumbag opportunist criminals even. It can alert me to their presence, annoy and harass and distract them yes. But fight them? In no way is that desirable, and on top of that there's just the rest of the time when I'd like my dog to be suited to catching me food, which unfortunately will imply sacrificing an aptitude for close quarter combat. But it's totally worth the sacrifice, it's an easy choice to make. I can easily accept me and my dog will have to slink off when a grizzly bear or gang of mad-maxesque baddies comes into our area. It will be an inconvenience but a reasonable one. Then we can go catch fast game consistently and thrive somewhere else. Conversely I try to imagine going the bad ass protection dog route. Ok so we sit around with the dog whining at me cause it's hungry and I'm like "yeah I bet you are hungry you needlessly big fat oaf, me too" and then the gang of mad max guys come and my cool dog runs over and chews on one while the others lash it to death with big chains, and I'm like "well what the hell was the point of that?". Replace the mad max guys with a bear, and even replace the dog with a sensible LGD that smartly wards it off, that's a little better but still the celebration will be short-lived cause we'll just go back to sitting around looking at eachother and being hungry. I could have had some collie/grey lurcher with me that just distracted and annoyed the bear while I slunk away, then caught up and helped me catch 5 rabbits in 2 hours that I could stew in a pot while I used my free time to build a new shelter. I really think I'm just being practical.
        • [quote1332759432=cawkazn]I cant help but think other hungry humans would just look at dogs as a food source. So your manning your property, some intruders come, your dogs rush the fence barking and alerting you etc. and they shoot your dogs from the safety of the otherside of the fence, and then eat them. [/quote1332759432] Unlike some...I am not referring to "dooms day" or "zombie day." I am only referring to typical collapses in society that have happened in the past during tough times that have followed economic collapses or government changes. With that in perspective...I Agree that having a bunch of dogs (food source) would make you a target. So would having a garden. You would want dried foods on storage that would last months and months. and plenty of ammo. I have both already. I have a water supply too. A dog or two kept under control may not make one a target. I would depend upon the visibility of that dog. Astibus, you have problems with others assuming things, but look at yourself. You too assume. You assume Little Hurtin is up for breeding. How often have I announced dogs available for sale on this board? How often have I made breeding announcements here? You're such a skeptic and it reflects a great deal on your inner peace. Little Hurtin is is a great prospect IMO for wilderness survival. Lynn however is a bit older than I would want for a survival dog. Preacher has too much mass for serve as an all around survival dog. Tate would be ok, but I sold him. I only picked Little Hurtin because I like her. Get your panties out of a bunch and relax. Also, you assume people have no experience in the wild. I have spent a LOT OF TIME in nature. I have spent a week with a man by the name of [link=http://keepitsimplearchery.webs.com/garysentmansinfluence.htm]Gary Sentman[/link]...a man that lived off the land for 10 years in Alaska without electricity. I also spent time with Madison Parker, a man that lived 6 years in Florida without electricity and who teaches wilderness living and survival courses. I think both know a bit about trapping and surviving. I have hunted my entire life. Have I "had to" live off the land, nope...but preparations are not paranoia. Does one have a fire extinguisher because they fear fire? Does one use a seat belt because they fear a wreck? Or, are they just making little "preparations" in case an unfortunate situation arises? I think the later.
          • Here's what I'd LIKE to take to survive in the wilderness vs what I think would actually be ideal. Maybe a subtle difference at first glance but a pretty significant one really. The first is a bully stag (ebt x deerhound/greyhound), the second a collie x greyhound. Mind you I think the first dog would still be handy, and in australia I'm pretty sure I'd get away with it due to the lack of large predators. Being able to catch the abundant hogs would be good too, as well as the kangaroos, wallabies, rabbits, deer, etc bully stags are known to be able to catch. But yeah in america (or most anywhere else in the world), I think BECAUSE of the threatening predators I want a more cautious, smarter dog. I actually want a "weaker" less combative dog because of the threats, not a more combative one.
            • I can understand that. What one would need REALLY depends upon WHY we are in "survival mode." If recreation...non-combative dog would be good. If primitive lifestyle...a non-combative dog would be good. If dealing with "zombies" (infectious disease / biological warfare)...a non combative but highly alert dog would be good. If dealing with a lawless society (revolutionary war, civil war, great depression, economic collapse, EMP pulse, etc)...a highly combative, highly alert, good hunter that has SOLID OBEDIENCE would be desired. I myself...being a father with kids...am not concerned about recreation or a "survival type" (as in the TV show) primitive man in nature setting. I am also not able to see myself in a "zombie" biological warfare state...as that would be very difficult to imagine what one would have to be willing to do to survive (I can't see myself as being successful in such a situation). But, in a somewhat anarchy setting...one that has happened to SOME DEGREE three times in American history...this is the situation that would put me on "survival mode," and this situation is one that I also see as "most likely" and also one that I am most able to prepare for.
              • I will take one of these for protection and big game hunting. And one of these to get me small meals lol
                • It has been a long time...generations...since America has had chaos in its homeland...and we have gotten soft here for that reason. The revolutionary war, the civil war, and great depression were the three greatest stresses on life here in the US to NEARLY all citizens. Yes, we have had WWI, WWII, Vietnam, Iraq wars...etc...but those wars were overseas and for the most part only REALLY affected military personal directly...and everyone else indirectly...since the chaos was somewhere else. We didn't see fighting on our front door. That was NOT the case in the revolutionary war, civil war, and great depression. These three had a DIRECT AND PERSONAL...and on our front yards...and in our homes. We have forgotten the need of protection and have gotten soft as a nation as a result of being "secure and comfortable." How long will our comfort and security last? Who knows...but regardless of what some may want you to believe...history shows peace is temporary. Societies collapse. War happens. It will some day be at our front door. Will this happen in my lifetime? My children's lifetime? One can speculate...but regardless of when, what we do know is it will happen. So, that was the setting I was thinking of. The other situations (recreational yearly vacation into the outback) isn't going to happen to me...I've got kids. So, if I go into the wilderness with my family, it would be because I had to. Is it "crazy" to consider such? If you think so...by all means feel that way; however, history shows us...it will happen. If you doubt it, well, that is because you live in a secure country...for now anyway.
                  • [quote1332779015=Astibus]What's this infantile fascination with doomsday in America lately? [/quote1332779015] It has little or nothing to do with "Zombies"...Instead, I think it has more to do with things like Patriot Act, NDAA, 2nd amendment ban attempts, executive orders being used to write laws (instead of following the balance of powers outlined in the constitution), laws passed to prevent wallstreet protestors or tea party groups (violating 1st amendment protection)...fear of forced socialism...and possible tyranny on the horizon as society structures have a tendency of revolving. People fear that the mindset of freedom and independence is fading. I find it funny that some people often SAY they believe in freedom, but meanwhile ACT in a way that illustrates tolerance only towards those that agree with them. What happened to "speak freely so the truth can present itself," or "agree to disagree" or "do what you want as long as you're not in my business?" It amazes me how don't want to discuss different ideas...but instead what to stop opposing views completely by force or law...instead of tolerating freedom of behavior or free open debate (speech). This is what scares many Americans...and that is why you see this topic more now in America than ever. Some people remember the blood that was spilled to build this nation. Others have forgotten due to not seeing it in their lifetime up close and personal. It isn't because Americans want to go camping on survival TV series. Yes, there are those people too, but the majority of "zombie" fanatics are more concerned with government collapse. This doesn't mean they really fear biological warfare or WWIII with nuclear weapons and that they are the only survivor. It could be something as minor as a collapse in the value of the dollar, as occurred in Zimbabwe in recent times. [quote]It's mostly quiet, uneventful, beautiful nature. You have lots of time to think about all kinds of stuff, no reason to rush anywhere, and at the end the feeling of accomplishment that you've actually mastered a period of time off the grid, in complete sync with nature. That in itself is very cool ... and peaceful. Sure it's tough and challenging at times, but it's totally worth it.[/quote] Agreed! That is EXACTLY why I said forget about bears, mountain lions, wolves etc...they wouldn't be of great concern. Do people get killed by such...yes, but many more people die from a lack of shelter or food. In nature, the main predator I would want to watch out for would be other humans. Away from humans, nature is generally peaceful and uneventful. In that regard, I agree.
                    • Wow, I must have pushed someone's button. LOL The US has over 300 million citizens now. The LAST thing they have to worry about is a total collapse of society. Rather actually a gradual trend towards a totalitarian system, as more and more regulation is being proposed to manage that many people. That would then be the exact opposite of anarchy and collapse. Agriculture is a prime example, where the necessity to feed this many inhabitants requires massive consolidation and a rigorous food industrialization. This is what transforms society, not EMPs. Maybe these latent doomsday 'desires' are an escape fantasy, a reaction to (or denial of) what's actually going on in the real world. Anyways. [quote=LeeRobinson]Astibus, you have problems with others assuming things, but look at yourself. You too assume. You assume Little Hurtin is up for breeding. How often have I announced dogs available for sale on this board? How often have I made breeding announcements here? You're such a skeptic and it reflects a great deal on your inner peace. [..] Get your panties out of a bunch and relax. Also, you assume people have no experience in the wild. [/quote] Boy, you're being sensitive. :) I just commented on your ever present self-promotion. Where somehow the bandog always ends up being portrayed as the ultimate super-duper dog in ... pretty much EVERYTHING. If that were indeed so, why do all the other breeds even exist, I wonder. See, for my own dog type, I always point out that they only excel in one scenario, pretection of their "family" in a rural setting. In most other settings they simply suck. But not so the Bandog, they practically dominate everything, family companion, fight, obedience, hunting, protection, city, wilderness, farms, outer space, you name it. That portayal is sooo laughable that most serious dog people can only roll their eyes. By the way, I am very relaxed but your avalanche of responses indicates that you may be in distress? Also, I never assumed that you had no experience in the wild. I just pointed out that all this hypothetical speculation about which dog would theoretically be the ultimate survival dog should really be replaced with reports of actual hands-on experiences. That would actually make sense. As for the hunting requirement, taking a big game hunting dog to an extended survival trip into the wilderness of today's real world will likely end you up in jail for poaching. Just saying. So if rabbits have to be on your menu, Tonedog's proposed dogs will likely do. In my case, a simple fishing line and hooks allowed me to take an LGD along without starving or violating laws. But please continue dreaming on how your huntin' dawg will save the (dooms)day by taking down elk and such. :) P.S.: I removed a paragraph from this post because I erroneously read "can" instead of "can't" in a quote, so that comment made no sense any longer.
                      • [quote1332796197=Astibus] Wow, I must have pushed someone's button. LOL [/quote1332796197] Not really. Just telling it like it is. You need to get out of your box more...and assume too much is all. And, you should hole yourself to the same standard you expect from others. That is all I am saying...that and then clarifying your misconceptions. [quote] The US has over 300 million citizens now. The LAST thing they have to worry about is a total collapse of society. Rather actually a gradual trend towards a totalitarian system, as more and more regulation is being proposed to manage that many people. That would then be the exact opposite of anarchy and collapse [/quote] What do you think follows totalitarianism? Overthrown government...be it an over thrown totalitarian one...or an over thrown corrupt socialistic one (which revolves into an eventual communism or totalitarianism)...either way...immediately following an overthrown government results in temporary anarchy. Not good...none of which are good. A good republic society is the best of these necessary "evils" (as our forefathers stated). [quote]Agriculture is a prime example, where the necessity to feed this many inhabitants requires massive consolidation and a rigorous food industrialization. [/quote] I would rather die free than be enslaved. [quote]This is what transforms society, not EMPs. Maybe these latent doomsday 'desires' are an escape fantasy, a reaction to (or denial of) what's actually going on in reality. Anyways.[/quote] The comment about EMP's had nothing to do with anarchy. Anarchy might FOLLOW such, but it wouldn't cause such. An EMP is to disrupt unification and break ordered systems...so, it would just be one cause. Who would use an EMP...who knows. Anyone trying to disrupt an opposing system of people. [quote] Boy, you're sensitive. :) [/quote] Nice cover up. I'm not at all sensitive. I just call your boat load of crap what it is...crap. It is a shame that someone as intelligent as yourself doesn't share any real value to the topic, but instead wishes to crap on other people ideas of views and does so without posting anything of substance. That's how I see it. Your post is just nonsense. Did I create this topic? No...I did not. What would cause me to "go in survival mode" might be different that your motivation to do such...so I was speaking about MY perspective. If you wanted to go "survival" by all means...tell us about the dog you would use for whatever situation would cause you to resort to such, but don't come here crapping on other views that you are too limited in comprehension to understand. [quote]I just commented on your ever present self-promotion.[/quote] No you didn't. You made false implications. I can't even recall the last time I mentioned anything here for sale. You have an issue with me...so at least be man enough to admit it. My response to you is not one of "sensitivity," but instead of one calling the pot black. Don't be a hypocrite. [quote] Where somehow the bandog always ends up being portrayed as the ultimate super-duper dog in ... pretty much EVERYTHING. [/quote] That's funny...being the "shar" is today's super molosser. I recall just a few years ago the super dog was the Neapolitan. What's next? There is no "super dog" Astibus. For me however, and MY desires...I like certain things for my lifestyle. You like the shar. Great. What's wrong with that. Our dogs are proven to work WITH people. Our dogs do PP work. Our dogs catch game. Does that mean yours are less than mine...nope...it just means they are not what I would want...but guess what...there are other fans of these dogs and YOUR dogs besides me and you. Its called...different strokes for different folks. When do you see me attacking shars? Really? I don't. I only say...where's the proof of their working abilities. You can love your Shars...and so can others. That's great. But not everyone likes the same thing. That's great too. You like to crap on other peoples dogs... [quote]If that were indeed so, why do all the other breeds even exist, I wonder.[/quote] See above. [quote] As for the hunting requirement, taking a big game hunting dog to an extended survival trip into the wilderness of today's real world will likely end you up in jail for poaching. Just saying.[/quote] Not in the scenario that resulted in me going "in wilderness survival mode." That would require law and order...and if that was the scenario...well, I would be home on the computer rebutting your nonsense on occasion...as I am now. ;) The simple fact that you keep thinking naturally protective trumps a trained protection dog illustrates you don't understand what training is for when dealing with a dog that is already naturally protective. It isn't to make a dog protective, but is to control the dog. We are not talking about Schutzhund routines here...but just "out" and "off" so the dog doesn't send into something it shouldn't. Open your eyes !disgust to what someone might be saying instead of resulting into a delusional, distorted, and shallow interpretation...and we can avoid this nonsense. Capiche?
                        • And btw, before making more false accusations as to me claiming our dogs are the best at everything, why don't you try reading the ONE PARAGRAPH on our [link=http://www.chimerakennels.com/]home page[/link]? See, I don't delude myself. If I had a livestock flock of sheep that needed guarding, I would consider a Shar...but guess what...I don't have one. Do you have sheep? One of my dogs wouldn't be a wise choice for such IMO, as they might hunt the flock. If I wanted a dog to retrieve ducks, I would get a retriever, not one of my dogs. If I wanted to compete in SchH or do patrol work and didn't need the dog to live with my family, I would check into a malinois or a Dutchie. If I wanted a dog to win races...I would get a greyhound. If I wanted a dog for ________, I would get a dog bred for _________. It just so happens, I got a dog for what I want...because what I want is what I want...and that is what our dogs are bred to excel at. What do I want? You can [link=http://www.chimerakennels.com/aboutchimerakennels.htm]look here and see...[/link] Next time, make an educated response. BTW, I suppose you would lay down and follow the instructions of a totalitarian ruler...like Hitler? Not me. We are not in those days anymore. Education can be a presentation...but only if one is prepared and doesn't accept the lies. [link=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDKcF--1hEc]Check out this video about such governments[/link]. [link=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O22S9hyrheg]Or this one... [/link]
                          • [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] You need to get out of your box more...and assume too much is all. And, you should hole yourself to the same standard you expect from others. That is all I am saying [..] The simple fact that you keep thinking naturally protective trumps a trained protection dog illustrates you don't understand what training is for when dealing with a dog that is already naturally protective. It isn't to make a dog protective, but is to control the dog. [/quote1332799469] LOL. Here you assume that a) I don't get out of my box enough b) that I don't understand dog training (because I own Shars?) c) that I think training is to make dogs protective and not to control them Yet YOU state that I assume too much. ;) [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] What do you think follows totalitarianism? Overthrown government...be it an over thrown totalitarian one...or an over thrown corrupt socialistic one (which revolves into an eventual communism or totalitarianism)...either way...immediately following an overthrown government results in temporary anarchy. Not good... [/quote1332799469] Well, if you look at historic facts, overthrown totalitarian systems in Germany, Italy, Japan after WWII resulted in democracy, not anarchy. Overthrown socialist systems (Soviet Union, Poland, Bulgaria, Rumania, Czechoslovakia etc) after the iron curtain collapsed resulted in democracy, again not anarchy. Overthrown monarchist systems (France, USA) resulted in democracy, not anarchy. The period of brief anarchy was always very very short lived. Not really worth preparing for. Moreover since totalitarian systems last for quite a while before enough momentum exists to overthrow them (see Lybia, Egypt, Tunesia). So my advice would be not to prepare for anarchy but to focus on keeping a society free. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] A good republic society is the best of these necessary "evils" (as our forefathers stated). [/quote1332799469] A republic is just a form (as in architecture) of government, it does not really imply the political system. Technically the Soviet Union was a republic. So is the Federal Republic of Germany. And of course the People's Republic of China. I highly doubt that is what you meant. Wouldn't it rather be the democratic system and personal freedoms that you mean to cherish? But I may just be assuming too much again. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]Agriculture is a prime example, where the necessity to feed this many inhabitants requires massive consolidation and a rigorous food industrialization. [/quote] I would rather die free than be enslaved. [/quote1332799469] Totally agreed. Nevertheless this country is slowly transforming. My example was to show that it sure ain't towards anarchy. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] If you wanted to go "survival" by all means...tell us about the dog you would use for whatever situation would cause you to resort to such, but don't come here crapping on other views that you are too limited in comprehension to understand.[/quote1332799469] Uhm, I live in Montana, and I've done extended trips. Here, in the real wilderness, not in some hypothetical future, where lawless mutants roam the planet. So how is my real-life perspective crap, but wild speculation about tough dogs in hypothetical worlds valid? [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]I just commented on your ever present self-promotion.[/quote] You have an issue with me...so at least be man enough to admit it. [/quote1332799469] Not at all actually. Not even with your dogs. Some of your bandogs I actually find more attractive than most bull-derivatives I've seen. But regardless, I have never met your dogs in person, therefore I completely refrain from judgement. I just never buy that "better in every aspect" mantra, let's just call it common sense. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote] Where somehow the bandog always ends up being portrayed as the ultimate super-duper dog in ... pretty much EVERYTHING. [/quote] That's funny...being the "shar" is today's super molosser. I recall just a few years ago the super dog was the Neapolitan. What's next? There is no "super dog" Astibus. [/quote1332799469] The Shar is a pretty exceptional LGD, it most certainly is NOT today's super molosser. On this forum I'm virtually the only Shar enthusiast advocating that dog type. I can't recall ever stating that the Neo was a super dog. Others may have, but I don't control what others believe. Bandog people however seem to believe that Neo's are some "super dog" because it's them who cross the Neo into their mixes, isn't it? So it's a little schizophrenic that you throw Neo's popularity into my face, if anything it should be the other way around. This board used to be very CO heavy, I'll give you that. These days it seems to be all about bandogs. But I don't think it will ever turn into a Shar fan forum. Ever. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] For me however, and MY desires...I like certain things for my lifestyle. You like the shar. Great. What's wrong with that. [/quote1332799469] Nothing. Which is why I provide a different perspective in these discussions where it mostly revolves around bully-derived "bandogs" of some sort. (Just look at the avatars and you know what I mean). I am doing this so people don't get the impression these are the only working dogs worth feeding. I advocate a very different paradigm altogether. It's definitely not for everyone, in fact Shars are hardly for anyone. But in certain settings, they rule. What's wrong with THAT? [u]Addendum:[/u] This thread is about the feasibility of dogs for survival in the wilderness. So what is wrong in proposing Shars, which are naturally protective and thrive in rural settings? Protection from wild animals, survival in rough environments, modest metabolism, that IS their very forte. As far as I am concerned, it's completely on topic. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]As for the hunting requirement, taking a big game hunting dog to an extended survival trip into the wilderness of today's real world will likely end you up in jail for poaching. Just saying.[/quote] Not in the scenario that resulted in me going "in wilderness survival mode." That would require law and order...and if that was the scenario...well, I would be home on the computer rebutting your nonsense on occasion...as I am now. ;) [/quote1332799469] Well, I like getting out of my box. I happen to like adventure. I don't wait for governments to collapse to explore America's great wilderness. And my computer is mostly for work, not so much for rebutting anyone's logorrhea. So I guess we're very different people. :)
                            • I saw this post of yours after I posted my response. [quote1332803785=LeeRobinson] Do you have sheep? [/quote1332803785] Yes. And the vast majority of my dogs are working the pastures. (But you know that already) [quote1332803785=LeeRobinson] Next time, make an educated response. BTW, I suppose you would lay down and follow the instructions of a totalitarian ruler...like Hitler? [/quote1332803785] Really?! You accuse me of making wild assumptions, then ask me to make an educated response .... and THEN you have the audacity to make such a f***ed up assumption?? Man, unlike you I actually experienced a whole bunch of totalitarian repression in my lifetime and my immediate family's lives. And I know how I DID act in those situations, not how I WOULD act. All you probably know is how you think you WOULD act, IF things happened. But guess what, talk is cheap my friend. The problem with totalitarian systems is that they function based on primal fear, people are scared to death to even make a move. Let me know when you've actually crossed borders in the middle of the night to help innocent people, while a totalitarian regime is waving kalashnikovs in your face. Because I did just that. So, when I point out very early stages of recent negative tendencies in this society, then it certainly isn't because I embrace them. What on earth makes you believe that I'm ever content with laying down and following instructions of any totalitarian rule?? This ought to be the most ignorant statement you've ever made on this forum.
                              • yeah the zombie thing is not what i mean at all theres no such things as zombies. more like if all the resources run out, electricity is gone etc. because one of those doomsday type events happening, when ppl cant raid the grocery store cause its empty they will look for food elsewhere. and stray dogs would be quick to go.
                                • [quote1332812363=Astibus] LOL. Here you assume that a) I don't get out of my box enough b) that I don't understand dog training (because I own Shars?) c) that I think training is to make dogs protective and not to control them Yet YOU state that I assume too much. ;) [/quote1332812363] It isn't an assumption on my part, but an assessment based upon several of the foolish statements you have made in the past about training a protection dog...something you have demonstrated a lack of understanding of time and time again. Even in this thread you gave again another foolish comment where you implied a trained dog is inferior to the natural dog? Have you ever considered having both...that is training the natural guardian? That, IMO, is ideal. [quote] [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] What do you think follows totalitarianism? Overthrown government...be it an over thrown totalitarian one...or an over thrown corrupt socialistic one (which revolves into an eventual communism or totalitarianism)...either way...immediately following an overthrown government results in temporary anarchy. Not good... [/quote1332799469] Well, if you look at historic facts, overthrown totalitarian systems in Germany, Italy, Japan after WWII resulted in democracy, not anarchy. Overthrown socialist systems (Soviet Union, Poland, Bulgaria, Rumania, Czechoslovakia etc) after the iron curtain collapsed resulted in democracy, again not anarchy. Overthrown monarchist systems (France, USA) resulted in democracy, not anarchy. [u]The period of brief anarchy was always very very short lived.[/u] Not really worth preparing for. Moreover since totalitarian systems last for quite a while before enough momentum exists to overthrow them (see Lybia, Egypt, Tunesia). So my advice would be not to prepare for anarchy but to focus on keeping a society free. [/quote] I find it ironic that while you try to disagree with me, in the middle of your post actually state I am after all...correct. Then you try to downplay the anarchy as so short lived it isn't worth mentioning. LOL. Your efforts display your subjective views...but meanwhile point out...I'm right...and you're once again full of nonsense. I find it ironic how we have so many times before seen you say I am wrong even though technically speaking I am right. You crack me up. Additionally, despite how short lived anarchy is...who wants to live in such? The raped victim? The one murdered or robbed? The one who has their last meal stolen and is beaten up? I don't think so. In fact, SOME societies have even begged for tyrants to return in order to establish SOME order after such anarchy have they not because that "short lived" anarchy was worse to them than the tyrant ever was (especially in areas with limited natural resources and competition motivated chaos). The world is different now. A collapse in such a densely populated area won't be days of the pilgrims in a new plentiful land. I prefer a republic system as established by "We the people of these united states..." (call it a democratic republic if that helps you understand despite that you already know what I am referring to...but want to argue about semantics...as such is your nature). [quote] Totally agreed. Nevertheless this country is slowly transforming. My example was to show that it sure ain't towards anarchy. [/quote] Despite your quoted text that I bolded and underlined for you above where you say I am correct? LOL. [quote] [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] If you wanted to go "survival" by all means...tell us about the dog you would use for whatever situation would cause you to resort to such, but don't come here crapping on other views that you are too limited in comprehension to understand.[/quote1332799469] Uhm, I live in Montana, and I've done extended trips. Here, in the real wilderness, not in some hypothetical future, where lawless mutants roam the planet. So how is my real-life perspective crap, but wild speculation about tough dogs in hypothetical worlds valid? [/quote] Read that again...as apparently you don't get my reference as to why your post is crap. Your real life comments would be worth something. It is your nonsense reply that is crap...crapping on other people's views without understanding their perspective...and choosing to make sarcastic and harassing posts...when INSTEAD you could post something of value. Capiche? [quote] [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]I just commented on your ever present self-promotion.[/quote] You have an issue with me...so at least be man enough to admit it. [/quote1332799469] Not at all actually. [/quote] So, I'm "ever present self-promotion" according to you (even though I haven't been here for a few weeks now and your full of it again...as I don't recall advertising dogs for sale here in years)...and yet you don't have a problem with that ever present self promotion? LOL. Ya, and and I have some "ocean front property for sale in Arizona." [quote1332813894=Astibus] [quote1332803785=LeeRobinson] Do you have sheep? [/quote1332803785] Yes. And the vast majority of my dogs are working the pastures. (But you know that already) [/quote1332813894] Well then, it makes sense that you would want a live stock guardian for such? Have I EVER given you a hard time about your desires, needs, and/or preferences? No, I haven't. I have requested that you provide proof for some of your claims, but I haven't given you a hard time about your desires, needs, or preferences. Why can't you do the same? Let people like what they like, desire what they desire, and get what they believe best serves their needs instead of crapping on other people's perspectives, knowledge, and or experience. I only reply to you in such a manner when you crap on other people's views. A bandog topic comes up, and you post crap on it. A shar topic comes up and I don't give a crap (so I don't crap on it). They aren't what I like, desire, or need. The only time I question your shars is when you start ranting and raving how they are the best guardians on the planet or how some natural untrained guardian is superior to a natural guardian that is trained...or some other nonsense. [quote] [quote1332803785=LeeRobinson] BTW, I suppose you would lay down and follow the instructions of a totalitarian ruler...like Hitler? [/quote1332803785] Really?! You accuse me of making wild assumptions, then ask me to make an educated response .... and THEN you have the audacity to make such a f***ed up assumption?? Man, unlike you I actually experienced a whole bunch of totalitarian repression in my lifetime and my immediate family's lives. And I know how I DID act in those situations, not how I WOULD act. All you probably know is how you think you WOULD act, IF things happened. But guess what, talk is cheap my friend. The problem with totalitarian systems is that they function based on primal fear, people are scared to death to even make a move. Let me know when you've actually crossed borders in the middle of the night to help innocent people, while a totalitarian regime is waving kalashnikovs in your face. Because I did just that. So, when I point out very early stages of recent negative tendencies in this society, then it certainly isn't because I embrace them. What on earth makes you believe that I'm ever content with laying down and following instructions of any totalitarian rule?? This ought to be the most ignorant statement you've ever made on this forum. [/quote] Great. I however was referring to your post earlier...where YOU suggested what follows democracy is not anarchy, but some form of stable totalitarianism or such (despite the fact that again...above in bold and underlined...you admit I was technically right). To imply that firearms and or protection dogs are not worth having following a collapse of society implies compliance to such...for a lack of compliance to such would require some form of protection (firearms, dogs, etc) would it not...and apparently you think such efforts are hilarious given some of your earlier "crap" posts. I however wouldn't comply to such...and would appreciate any form of resistance I could muster up.
                                  • [quote1332814570=cawkazn] yeah the zombie thing is not what i mean at all theres no such things as zombies. more like if all the resources run out, electricity is gone etc. because one of those doomsday type events happening, when ppl cant raid the grocery store cause its empty they will look for food elsewhere. and stray dogs would be quick to go. [/quote1332814570] Exactly.
                                    • [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] [quote1332812363=Astibus] LOL. Here you assume that a) I don't get out of my box enough b) that I don't understand dog training (because I own Shars?) c) that I think training is to make dogs protective and not to control them Yet YOU state that I assume too much. ;) [/quote1332812363] It isn't an assumption on my part, but an assessment based upon several of the foolish statements you have made in the past about training a protection dog...something you have demonstrated a lack of understanding of time and time again. Even in this thread you gave again another foolish comment where you implied a trained dog is inferior to the natural dog? Have you ever considered having both...that is training the natural guardian? That, IMO, is ideal. [/quote1332818231] How insulting really. Despite numerous discussions you and I had that I used to train GSDs as a decoy. Now this complete distortion of my person and experience just to prove some point? Pathetic. What you fail to see is that a natural dog can have "both" as well. You just can't seem to process that it might be under a completely different paradigm. Maybe naturally protective with real world working experience is ideal. And not fake excercises with soft batons. That is where we fundamentally differ (regarding protection). [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] [quote] [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] What do you think follows totalitarianism? Overthrown government...be it an over thrown totalitarian one...or an over thrown corrupt socialistic one (which revolves into an eventual communism or totalitarianism)...either way...immediately following an overthrown government results in temporary anarchy. Not good... [/quote1332799469] Well, if you look at historic facts, overthrown totalitarian systems in Germany, Italy, Japan after WWII resulted in democracy, not anarchy. Overthrown socialist systems (Soviet Union, Poland, Bulgaria, Rumania, Czechoslovakia etc) after the iron curtain collapsed resulted in democracy, again not anarchy. Overthrown monarchist systems (France, USA) resulted in democracy, not anarchy. [u]The period of brief anarchy was always very very short lived.[/u] Not really worth preparing for. Moreover since totalitarian systems last for quite a while before enough momentum exists to overthrow them (see Lybia, Egypt, Tunesia). So my advice would be not to prepare for anarchy but to focus on keeping a society free. [/quote] I find it ironic that while you try to disagree with me, in the middle of your post actually state I am after all...correct. Then you try to downplay the anarchy as so short lived it isn't worth mentioning. LOL. Your efforts display your subjective views...but meanwhile point out...I'm right...and you're once again full of nonsense. I find it ironic how we have so many times before seen you say I am wrong even though technically speaking I am right. You crack me up. [/quote1332818231] Sometimes it's like talking to a toddler. OK, I am going to type really slow, so you can follow my train of thought .... After a system is overthrown, history teaches us that it is swiftly replaced by another system of government. A very very brief vacuum may occur right after the old system collapses, but the opportunists or victors will quickly cease the moment to establish a new system right away. No need to prepare for this brief transitional time beyond some reasonable measures, because it won't last anyway. People who think they can do what they want in that meantime usually end up dead .. or arrested once law and order is re-established. So no, you are absolutely NOT right in preparing for some future anarchist power vacuum, because it won't last. The best would be to keep a low profile and wait until the next system is established. Everyone in Europe knows that, for Americans it's been a while so they may not remember. [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] I prefer a republic system as established by "We the people of these united states..." (call it a democratic republic if that helps you understand despite that you already know what I am referring to...but want to argue about semantics...as such is your nature). [/quote1332818231] Not semantics at all. You just don't know what the term Republic means. See, if I said that I would like to eat fish egg caviar from whales and you correct me that whales are actually mammals so they don't produce fish eggs, then I can't really accuse you of arguing semantics. A republic is just an organizational model of government. It (almost) does not imply a political system. So a republic without democracy might just be your worst nightmare (again, see People's Republic of China maybe). Therefore it is not mere "semantics" when I explain to you that a republic is a different "animal" than what you think it is. I would only know what you are "referring to", if I interpreted your statement as indoctrinated "code" where like-minded folks wrongly refer to the same concept by misnaming it a "republic" as well. But just because you repeat what others say wrong doesn't make it right. [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] [quote] Totally agreed. Nevertheless this country is slowly transforming. My example was to show that it sure ain't towards anarchy. [/quote] Despite your quoted text that I bolded and underlined for you above where you say I am correct? LOL. [..] YOU suggested what follows democracy is not anarchy, but some form of stable totalitarianism or such (despite the fact that again...above in bold and underlined...you admit I was technically right) [/quote1332818231] You assume too much. ;) I didn't say you're correct, nor are you correct. You just cherry picked a miniscule detail and "bolded and underlined" it, that's all. So when a system gravitates towards totalitarian, sticks around for decades or more, until say the population eventually rises and overthrows it, then creates a momentary power vacuum (i.e. "anarchy") for maybe a few weeks, to quickly transition into a new stable government system (for better or worse), then all YOU hear is that anarchy is the main attribute here? So let me ask you then, if a US soldier does 2 consequtive rounds in Iraq, then returns home for two weeks to kick back a little and help with the household, only to be sent to Afghanistan for another year or more, would you then call him a home maker? Because technically he DID spend 2 weeks at home, right. Being "technically correct" can still be utterly wrong! Lee, you always do the same in discussions, you focus on some minor details and don't see the big picture. And when people point that out, your last resort is to call it "nonsense". So predictable. [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] Well then, it makes sense that you would want a live stock guardian for such? Have I EVER given you a hard time about your desires, needs, and/or preferences? No, I haven't. I have requested that you provide proof for some of your claims, but I haven't given you a hard time about your desires, needs, or preferences. Why can't you do the same? Let people like what they like, desire what they desire, and get what they believe best serves their needs instead of crapping on other people's perspectives, knowledge, and or experience. I only reply to you in such a manner when you crap on other people's views. A bandog topic comes up, and you post crap on it. A shar topic comes up and I don't give a crap (so I don't crap on it). [/quote1332818231] Alright, but how is THIS thread a bandog thread??! I fail to see that. So if it isn't, then I would assume that Shars CAN be discussed in the context of survival in the wilderness, NO? Or is "ultimate survival dog" strictly reserved for bandogs only, and I just didn't understand that? PLLLEASE! [quote1332818231=LeeRobinson] [quote] [quote1332803785=LeeRobinson] BTW, I suppose you would lay down and follow the instructions of a totalitarian ruler...like Hitler? [/quote1332803785] Really?! You accuse me of making wild assumptions, then ask me to make an educated response .... and THEN you have the audacity to make such a f***ed up assumption?? Man, unlike you I actually experienced a whole bunch of totalitarian repression in my lifetime and my immediate family's lives. And I know how I DID act in those situations, not how I WOULD act. [/quote] To imply that firearms and or protection dogs are not worth having following a collapse of society implies compliance to such...for a lack of compliance to such would require some form of protection (firearms, dogs, etc) would it not...and apparently you think such efforts are hilarious given some of your earlier "crap" posts. I however wouldn't comply to such...and would appreciate any form of resistance I could muster up. [/quote1332818231] I never implied that for a collapse of society firearms or dogs would be useless. What I said is that overthrown systems typically result in new systems. By the way, your naive Rambo approach in a totalitarian system will most likely get you (and your family!) annihilated before you can even reload. That's how totalitarian systems work, they punish your kids too, so others are afraid sh!tless. You don't think totalitarian systems have methods to deal with folks like you? Man, just look at South America, Asia, Russia, Nazi Germany. Nevertheless, that certainly doesn't mean one has to comply or lay down. Far from it. You just have to be smart about it. (If you don't know what I mean, watch Schindlers List perhaps). Ironically, here in Montana and Idaho we have the occasional hot head who tries to fight the federal government on his own. Armed to the teeth, it frequently ends up in some stupid shootout and guess who doesn't make it. Nevertheless, there are many folks here, who prepare for that ominous period of "anarchy", even though history teaches us that "anarchy" even after revolutions is merely transient. If it wasn't all so absurd, it would almost make more sense to rent a dog for those few weeks. lol
                                      • @davidfitness83 What kind of dog is Tango?
                                        • I believe Tango is an Alano Espanol.
                                          • [quote1332845080=Castanha] I believe Tango is an Alano Espanol. [/quote1332845080] You are correct :)
                                            • Astibus, really...I read about 1/10th of your reply in quick scan, and I see so many errors and arrogance that it just isn't worth another in depth off topic reply. Briefly, I will state... 1. You didn't even discuss dogs in that post other than saying you once trained dogs...says you. Anyone can claim that. Where's the proof that you knew what you were doing? Also, untrained means not taught. A trained dog is superior to an untrained dog of equal quality. Now, you want to down play training as requiring padded batons. They can be useful in some settings, but that is hardly a training requirement. More crap... 2. Anarchy is not something people want. Tyranny is not any better. You fail to acknowledge that I would resist either, as would many other Americans that are on a anti-"zombie" trip as you like to put it. 3. This isn't a bandog thread, nor a shar thread...but did I say my dog was the best for you? No...I did not. Did I crap on your ideal dog? No, I did not. You failed to open your eyes to other people's perspectives, experience, and knowledge...and chose to be disrespectful. You didn't question my reasoning, you disrespected it...and frankly, I think you have your head up your delusional and proverbial rear. 4. Where did I say that my choice of dog was the best choice for everyone and everything? Nope. I didn't. 5. And finally, your comparison of my reference to America being a republic to whale/fish caviar is simply ignorant. Whales are not fish for one, and whales don't lay eggs for two. (BTW, although I am not a caviar expert by any means, I believe Beluga caviar comes from a sturgeon...which is a fish). Like it or not; however, America is a republic. Are you saying America is not a republic? It doesn't matter if I completely described it as a democratic republic or not...because America is indeed a republic and you knew what I meant. Yet, you want to argue about it being a democracy. Guess what, America isn't a true democracy either. Your argument is a stupid time wasting disrespectful and argument over semantics and nothing more, and it is an incorrect at that. Give it a rest already. Enjoy.
                                              • It's always best to be prepared. I once read that no society is more then three days away from anarchy. Think about Hurricane Katrina. It took a week for FEMA to get its head out of its ass. A lot can happen in a week.
                                                • No doubt...and excellent point. Despite having resources that we have stored, most people don't take those preparations...and this creates competition for limited resources. I remember Katrina well. It was just a few hours south of where I lived. The DIRECT impact here was mild...with some competition for gas due to a knock out of electricity. Food wasn't really a problem...but without electricity, some panicked...worried about air conditioning during the hot summer. We were ok at my home...power was back on in short order for us because we were on a "top priority" grid...being close to a dry ice plant...which was important for hospitals and such. Regardless of that...we also had some of New Orlean's evacuees...and reports were that one man SHOT his OWN SISTER over a bag of ice. The worst part about Katrina was...people that survived the initial trama KNEW it was temporary and LOCALIZED, and knew that they would be ok...yet people STILL FREAKED OUT. People were put in martial law. Rights were violated. Yet, "anarchy" or "tyranny" isn't something we should concern ourselves with? Please...What's going to happen when people don't know what's going to happen? It won't be pretty.
                                                  • [quote1332868382=LeeRobinson] Astibus, really...I read about 1/10th of your reply in quick scan, [/quote1332868382] This is exactly your problem, you scan, you don't read. [quote1332868382=LeeRobinson] 5. And finally, your comparison of my reference to America being a republic to whale/fish caviar is simply ignorant. Whales are not fish for one, and whales don't lay eggs for two. (BTW, although I am not a caviar expert by any means, I believe Beluga caviar comes from a sturgeon...which is a fish). [/quote1332868382] If you actually read what I wrote, and perhaps even understood my analogy, you clearly wouldn't have made this ignorant remark. Scan on... [quote1332868382=LeeRobinson] Like it or not; however, America is a republic. Are you saying America is not a republic? It doesn't matter if I completely described it as a democratic republic or not...because America is indeed a republic and you knew what I meant. Yet, you want to argue about it being a democracy. Guess what, America isn't a true democracy either. Your argument is a stupid time wasting disrespectful and argument over semantics and nothing more, and it is an incorrect at that.[/quote1332868382] No, I am not saying America is not a republic. What I am saying is that being a republic means jack sh!t, since many really nasty societies are a republic too. Is that so hard to understand? Being a republic is just an organizational architecture, nothing more. I think you may be confused and assume that we are somehow arguing over democrats vs republicans, which we are not at all. Those two party names are somewhat unfortunate and have NOTHING to do with America being a democracy or a republic. So America isn't a democracy, good to know. What is it then, a fake democracy? Kinda like China? A republic, but not a true democracy? C'mon! The US is of course a republic, but that in itself is not key for why this society is free and prosper. If every state in the US installed a fasc!st regime, America would still be a republic, but not a very pleasant one. As for Katrina, I lived in Houston at the time (followed by the preparations for hurricane Rita which targeted Houston itself, but turned out to be relatively weak), so we also experienced it very close. This was as close as it got to "anarchy"....for a couple of weeks at best. Those that took the law into their own hand and acted like maniacs (i.e. looters, the police officers that decided to just shoot civilians) later often got arrested and are rotting in prison now. Anarchy is transient, and the best way of survival is to remain civil and wait it out. Moreover, during that time countless dogs were simply abandoned by their humans, so your argument really says that one shouldn't have a dog at all during those turbulent times. This would agree well with times of war in Europe, where dogs quickly get decimated to near extinction because they are just unnecessary ballast. My point is that survival is very different from fantasy. My goal was to encourage people to go out and try it in today's wonderful wilderness instead of speculating about hypothetical dystopic societies (or lack thereof). But it seems people prefer their fantasies over real experiences. Fine, you can only lead a horse to the water, you cannot make it drink. So please continue raving over fictitious scenarios in an hypothetical future, with romantic distortions of what survival would entail. Make hundreds of "friends" on facebook, take imaginary trips through anarchist landscapes, fight fictitious creatures with your super-duper dogs that are perfectly designed for a non-existing world. Meanwhile, I will continue to live in the real world and enjoy real wilderness. P.S.: How did this site get better since Mike, Al and Betsie left??! Weeks of NO post whatsoever (until I decided to post a thread on one of my females), only to be followed by juvenile "what if" discussions and "would" arguments. Awesome.
                                                    • 1. I have read your past replies...but eventually your crap eventually just begins to get old. 5. I read enough to know your analogy was invalid...as it was incorrect and inconclusive, while my statements was correct even if not "completely descriptive" to your satisfaction. The TRUTH IS, we were talking about AMERICANS...so, when I referred to "republic," you should have been able to recognize I was referring to a democratic republic...and not China. Yet, you wish to waste time for some somantic reason. Give it a rest. You look like a lost individual. [quote] As for Katrina, I lived in Houston at the time (followed by the preparations for hurricane Rita which targeted Houston itself, but turned out to be relatively weak), so we also experienced it very close. [u]This was as close as it got to "anarchy"....for a couple of weeks at best. Those that took the law into their own hand and acted like maniacs (i.e. looters, the police officers that decided to just shoot civilians)[/u] later often got arrested and are rotting in prison now. Anarchy is transient, and the best way of survival is to remain civil and wait it out. [/quote] When in survival mode...during anarchy...did those who committed crimes actually worry about what would follow? No, they did not...AND KATRINA WAS LOCALIZED & TEMPORARY PROBLEM. What would happen if it was national...and faith of a stable future was of great concern. Weather improves. Societies don't always do so....and despite this, people freaked out. [u]You once again your argument only proves your ignorance, and meanwhile proves my point...for for a while, it will be up to you to protect yourself[/u]. [quote] Moreover, during that time countless dogs were simply abandoned by their humans, so your argument really says that one shouldn't have a dog at all during those turbulent times. This would agree well with times of war in Europe, where dogs quickly get decimated to near extinction because they are just unnecessary ballast. [/quote] More reason to have either 1. a tough/protective dog that SERVES YOU, and/or 2. a small dog that doesn't eat much.
                                                      • [quote1332874839=LeeRobinson] I read enough to know your analogy was invalid...as it was incorrect and inconclusive, while my statements was correct ....(followed by paranoia, paranoia, paranoia.) [/quote1332874839] I am starting to feel sorry for you. You may need help my friend.
                                                        • Oh, I'm great. Got a great wife, two beautiful kids, a loving family, a stable job, good health, and some great dogs...and plenty of dried foods and ammo for anarchy. LOL. How about you? Apparently you think others will take care of you when "Katrina" or worse comes your way. Good luck with that.
                                                          • Oh I'm prepared. If "Katrina" actually comes to Montana, I'll have swimming arm floats to survive until I grow webbed feet and some gills to adapt to water world and hide from armed vigilantes. LOL
                                                            • I have a feelingwe got waaaay off the subject...lol Question was, one dog, one man surviving in the wilderness for a long, long, long time. I take my current dog in a heart beat!! She's got the toughness, protection instinct and power of the AB, the hunting skills of the catahoula and Black Mouth Cur, their agility, speed, stamina, nose etc. And her size gives her the advantge of being able to negotiate ANY type of terrain. I'll take my girl with no hesitation!
                                                              • Nico, I would say you have the perfect dog for your needs. I am glad she is doing so well. [quote1332880844=Astibus] Oh I'm prepared. If "Katrina" actually comes to Montana, I'll have swimming arm floats to survive until I grow webbed feet and some gills to adapt to water world and hide from armed vigilantes. LOL [/quote1332880844] You like to disrespect others so much, it is obvious you lack inner peace. What about the other stuff? Wife, kids, etc? What about them? Do you have such? If so, great...Count your blessings. If not, I wonder why. Actually...I don't. You remind me of the type that wants to participate in debate class, loses a competition and then tries to explain why you won despite no one else thinking so, and is left talking to them self saying "Well, actually...", meanwhile all the girls walked off leaving you to your lonesome self. You might think that is a bit harsh, but you know...you asked for it with your unnecessary disrespectful behavior on this forum....so don't cry about it stinking like crap here and now when you chose to throw such in the beginning. Instead, you should let people have their opinions. If you doubt their view, question it...but don't crap on it because your preferences are different and/or your comprehension is too limited to understand their views, desires, or needs. Grasp what is important in this life. You are missing that, and it shows given how you like to crap all over other people's views just because they prefer, desire, and need different things than you yourself do. Inner peace is great. I hope you find it some day. Live and let live. Don't always assume someone is up to pawning off something just because they like something. [u]When was the last time I ever announced anything for sale her? A LONG TIME ago. When was the last time I said our dogs are better than everything else in existence? Never. Yet, you wish to disrespect me without me confronting your desires. [/u] You don't know what you are talking about, and you are missing out in the bigger meaning of life. Perhaps you need God, but that of course is another topic...and probably one I won't be able to help you with. If you want reasonable and polite behavior, try offering it. Start with the man in the mirror.
                                                                • Can we get back to dogs..... this bash fest that always ensues between you 2 is old
                                                                  • @Lee, THAT is your response to a lighthearted joke?? Seriously?! I talk about [u]real[/u] wilderness experiences in Montana while you prepare for some fictional apocalyptic future. Yet I somehow lack inner peace and am "missing out in the bigger meaning of life". OK then. Without any implied malice, but I am beginning to think that your stubborn ignorant mantra in discussions has effectively killed this forum. Congrats. Have your last word. I'm out. :|
                                                                    • We also have to consider riots. Some last only a few hours. Others last for days. Some even lead to full scale revolutions. The chance of a full scale revolt happening is unlikely but civil unrest could force a person to have to bug out or bug in. I think in an urban environment a man could get by with a larger dog. Suppose your wife or child needed medicine? You would have to walk/drive down dangerous streets and then have to go into a store that might be full of looters. In this scenario a large mastiff type dog would work better. I grew up in the inner city and I know for a fact that two legged predators are just as opportunistic as four legged predators. You have to assume that some of the people that you meet are actually sizing you up. A determined criminal/bear/mountain lion will attack no matter what he sees but most, upon seeing that you are a hard target, will give you a wide berth.
                                                                      • Astibus, I wasn't joking. I am just letting you know what I really think about you based upon your behavior. You need to let others have their own views. Question them if you want, but don't crap on what you don't understand just because it doesn't fit your desires. If you would keep your responses professional, instead of personal and sarcastic, we could avoid this stuff.
                                                                        • In like an apocolyptic urban scenario a bandog would be great. But where did either the apocalyptic or urban thing come from? This was about wild survival, nothing to do with either of those things. I took it to mean if you and a dog could go out into the wilderness and try and live off the land, which dog would be best suited. Pretty sure that's how the thread was intended. Societal collapse, riots, zombies, etc, all irrelevant as far as I can make out.
                                                                          • Where do you think those urban people will go when they can't find food at an empty grocery store...and they don't see hope for improvement soon? They will be forced to look for food storage (raids) OR go to nature.
                                                                            • That's what I mean though, was societal collapse even specified? Why are these urban people coming out to the wilderness? The whole point was to get away from them lol! I dunno, I guess this hypothetical can be approached from a lot of different ways, and for me I didn't imagine an apocalypse or societal collapse but rather myself choosing to go and live off the land, and what dog would be most useful to do this if you had to choose just one. In my mind it could be a bear gryls type one man adventure (or one man and one dog in this instance), or even setting up a "log cabin" home with your family and subsisting off the land. No big fundamental difference there, but to introduce an apocalypse and looters and plunderers and/or zombies etc then you're turning it into something else.
                                                                              • Understood. There are several reasons why we could go into nature. We do it regularly here...although we don't go for weeks at a time, nor do we do it to survive. We do it for recreation. I have spent time kayaking down rivers (and even up rivers)...gone to places we didn't have access to and stayed there for some time...but that was always for recreation, and not "survival." It was the word "survival" that made me think of a different twist.
                                                                                • Fair enough. That's as valid a fantasy scenario to hypothesise as any other I suppose. Just wasn't what I was thinking. I have an interest in "surviving" off nature rather than off society. Just because I think it would be more rewarding and healthy. I have a child on the way myself, and the thought of raising a child in a rugged wild natural way is pretty appealing. So far all me and my girlfriend have is a very large and diverse vegetable garden, as well as fruit and nut and etc-bearing plants in nearby forests that we gather. Not much, but it's a start. I'd like to become increasingly less and less reliant on "society", move further out on a bigger piece of property (bigger the better, thousands of acres would be ideal) and "graduate" from not buying vegetables, to also not buying meat, and not getting water from the council but from tanks and/or springs and creeks, and building furniture and etc out of wood from trees I chopped down, and etc etc etc. So I was coming at it more from that angle, but maybe imagining it being even more wild than I want in my future just for interest's sake. Just what dog could best aid you in living a more simple self-sustaining life off the land. A sighthound cross seems the pretty obvious choice for me. Maybe a more fun question, albeit easier, would be what 5 or 6 dogs would you have? You wouldn't want 6 if you were "bear grylsing" it, but maybe if instead like I mentioned you were establishing a little log cabin settlement with your family on "400 000 acres" (or whatever) of varying wilderness terrain. Might be fun to think about what kind of pack you'd put together. If you and astibus say 6 bandogs and 6 sars, respectively, I give up. LOL!
                                                                                  • As for how we got on to the urban type survival dogs. That was my suggestion. Everyone had pretty much said thier opinions and the thread was ending. I think the general consensus was something basically cur like. So since everyone had made their point and I'd was getting repetitive. I suggested a new envornment, a more dangerous one. That's how conversations go, they move from one point to the next as they evolve and change. Was their anything else to be said about wilderness survival dog types? I was thinking afterward I'd like to see everyone's opinion on arctic survival with a dog then desert survival. I think in an arctic situation I'd like a Malamute trained to pull. In a desert I can't imagine a dog being anything more than a meal. To those who imagine western civilization will last for eternity, history disagrees with you. Civilizations change government's are conquered or collapse nothing is perfect and nothing lasts forever. Rome lasted 1000 years and collapsed we've only been here 200 and think we're invincible. To me that's just silly. Even the American Red cross recommends every American family have a disaster survival kit and an emergency evacuation plan so people can "bug out" if need be. I understand how tempting it can be to feel like nothing wil ever change and we and our families are secure from the kind of horrors that Asia, Africa, the Middle East, and Europe have all suffered in very recent history. Because this is America right? Nothing bad can happen here. Except that it can (and no I'm not thinking zombies let's leave that to the teenagers). I think we Americans are a little too cocky about our vulnerability. if the planes on 9-11 had taken out Hoover dam and a few key power plants some people would have been in the dark for years. Mostly in the west and Midwest, maybe even Montana. In the end being prepared just shows forthought. Especially for a man with young children and a family that depend on him failing to stay prepared for a disaster on any scale is irresponsible. So I keep fresh batteries in my smoke and carbon monoxide detectors, I do the occasional fire drill with the kids. I have a battery opperated weather radio for tornados etc, and I keep emergency food, water, fuel, etc on hand. I also have over a decade of martial arts training, trained protection dogs, and fire arms training. I know a lot of people feel like the police and government will always come and save you. But I have literally stared down the barrel of shotguns while men in masks demanded I lay on the ground while they break into my home, with my family. No PD in the world is fast enough to save you from that. So that night I saved my own family because I was prepared and if it happens again I'll do it again. Btw during Katrina my family didn't have power or water for a full week, and you couldn't get gas for longer. Good thing we were prepared huh? Maybe I'm just old fashioned.
                                                                                    • Good question Tonedog if i was to put together a pack id want a little of everything... id take 2 LGD Sars or even COs since these dogs would also be used to defend the house and also guard any deer or random livestock id manage to "domesticate".....then id have 2 bay/tracking dogs for this id take 2 black mouth cur.. lastly id have 2 good catch dogs and i would use bandogs but more the Australian Bandog and less the American since i need less protection from these dogs (since if have the good old LGD's) and more the ability to catch small game as well as large
                                                                                      • * 1 Beauceron and 1 Malinois for patroling and protecting family and guard live stock. * 1 Catahoula and 1 Black Mouth Cur for hunting/baying. * 1 Alano Espanol and 1 AB/Catahoula/Black Mouth Cur (my girl...lol) for hunting/catching and protecting. *...and a bunch of cats to take care of the little stuff...lol *
                                                                                        • I am still leaning toward a smaller dog for wilderness survival. I like Patterdales Terriers. Here's a couple baying and catching a hog. [youtube]oDDOIHK3KaM[/youtube] A nice hog caught by two dogs that you can carry under your arm or in a gunny sack. They are also good on squirrels, rabbit and, if push come to shove, rats.
                                                                                          • [quote1332971484=Tonedog] If you and astibus say 6 bandogs and 6 sars, respectively, I give up. LOL! [/quote1332971484] ROTFLO! I would like a few of my current dogs...but some other breeds that have interested me are those hunting whippets and the australian cattle dog. For some reason, almost every ASC I have seen displays almost no tuck up and I wonder if those dogs really have a sausage build, or if they are just eating a poor diet. I think a well conditioned ACD would be an interesting K9. Whippets because of their sight hound abilities. I would love to see a whippet made a bit more durable though (here we go with those "APBT" crosses again...hahaha).
                                                                                            • I think a bedlington terrier whippet cross would be a great for hunting small game. http://dogwebs.net/C.Square/Lurchers.asp
                                                                                              • One great thing about these dogs is that they could run through thick brush.
                                                                                                • Not that it matters to anyone here...but former US Navy Seal Madison Parker teaches wilderness living and has even instructed other the Navy Seals with some techniques as to how to survive in the wild. Guess what his dog of choice is. If you guessed APBT, you are 100% correct. And, it was a Sorrells' dog at that. For those interested, I suspect at 14 minutes that is his APBT in the background... [youtube]aJ_u5Y04ox0[/youtube] BTW, Madison gave me one of his sling shots and "drop" spears about some years back. It has been a while since I have spoke to him.
                                                                                                    • @akumal These dogs are beautiful. Are they one of the more popular hunting breeds in Japan?
                                                                                                      • [quote1333848754=Astibus] [quote1332874839=LeeRobinson] I read enough to know your analogy was invalid...as it was incorrect and inconclusive, while my statements was correct ....(followed by paranoia, paranoia, paranoia.) [/quote1332874839] I am starting to feel sorry for you. You may need help my friend. [/quote1333848754] [quote1333848781=LeeRobinson] Oh, I'm great. Got a great wife, two beautiful kids, a loving family, a stable job, good health, and some great dogs...and plenty of dried foods and ammo for anarchy. LOL. How about you? Apparently you think others will take care of you when "Katrina" or worse comes your way. Good luck with that. [/quote1333848781] You should be less worried about a bad revolution or despotism in the USA, as this is very unlikely to happen, than being worried about the renaissance when it comes to producing coal! China as well as the USA cause a big problem there.
                                                                                                        Login or Join to comment.

                                                                                                        cawkazn
                                                                                                        •  ·  Moderator
                                                                                                        • D

                                                                                                          1

                                                                                                          A

                                                                                                          84 friends
                                                                                                        • M

                                                                                                          8 followers
                                                                                                        • 13389 views

                                                                                                        Partaken

                                                                                                        The Campeiro Bulldog
                                                                                                        Feeding a Raw Diet
                                                                                                        Pics of fila X apbt
                                                                                                        why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
                                                                                                        American Bully
                                                                                                        question about socialization with a fila
                                                                                                        Am I Asking For Too Much...?
                                                                                                        Serbian defense dog