Comment '[quote1332799469=Lee...' to 'ultimate survival dog'

  • [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] You need to get out of your box more...and assume too much is all. And, you should hole yourself to the same standard you expect from others. That is all I am saying [..] The simple fact that you keep thinking naturally protective trumps a trained protection dog illustrates you don't understand what training is for when dealing with a dog that is already naturally protective. It isn't to make a dog protective, but is to control the dog. [/quote1332799469] LOL. Here you assume that a) I don't get out of my box enough b) that I don't understand dog training (because I own Shars?) c) that I think training is to make dogs protective and not to control them Yet YOU state that I assume too much. ;) [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] What do you think follows totalitarianism? Overthrown government...be it an over thrown totalitarian one...or an over thrown corrupt socialistic one (which revolves into an eventual communism or totalitarianism)...either way...immediately following an overthrown government results in temporary anarchy. Not good... [/quote1332799469] Well, if you look at historic facts, overthrown totalitarian systems in Germany, Italy, Japan after WWII resulted in democracy, not anarchy. Overthrown socialist systems (Soviet Union, Poland, Bulgaria, Rumania, Czechoslovakia etc) after the iron curtain collapsed resulted in democracy, again not anarchy. Overthrown monarchist systems (France, USA) resulted in democracy, not anarchy. The period of brief anarchy was always very very short lived. Not really worth preparing for. Moreover since totalitarian systems last for quite a while before enough momentum exists to overthrow them (see Lybia, Egypt, Tunesia). So my advice would be not to prepare for anarchy but to focus on keeping a society free. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] A good republic society is the best of these necessary "evils" (as our forefathers stated). [/quote1332799469] A republic is just a form (as in architecture) of government, it does not really imply the political system. Technically the Soviet Union was a republic. So is the Federal Republic of Germany. And of course the People's Republic of China. I highly doubt that is what you meant. Wouldn't it rather be the democratic system and personal freedoms that you mean to cherish? But I may just be assuming too much again. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]Agriculture is a prime example, where the necessity to feed this many inhabitants requires massive consolidation and a rigorous food industrialization. [/quote] I would rather die free than be enslaved. [/quote1332799469] Totally agreed. Nevertheless this country is slowly transforming. My example was to show that it sure ain't towards anarchy. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] If you wanted to go "survival" by all means...tell us about the dog you would use for whatever situation would cause you to resort to such, but don't come here crapping on other views that you are too limited in comprehension to understand.[/quote1332799469] Uhm, I live in Montana, and I've done extended trips. Here, in the real wilderness, not in some hypothetical future, where lawless mutants roam the planet. So how is my real-life perspective crap, but wild speculation about tough dogs in hypothetical worlds valid? [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]I just commented on your ever present self-promotion.[/quote] You have an issue with me...so at least be man enough to admit it. [/quote1332799469] Not at all actually. Not even with your dogs. Some of your bandogs I actually find more attractive than most bull-derivatives I've seen. But regardless, I have never met your dogs in person, therefore I completely refrain from judgement. I just never buy that "better in every aspect" mantra, let's just call it common sense. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote] Where somehow the bandog always ends up being portrayed as the ultimate super-duper dog in ... pretty much EVERYTHING. [/quote] That's funny...being the "shar" is today's super molosser. I recall just a few years ago the super dog was the Neapolitan. What's next? There is no "super dog" Astibus. [/quote1332799469] The Shar is a pretty exceptional LGD, it most certainly is NOT today's super molosser. On this forum I'm virtually the only Shar enthusiast advocating that dog type. I can't recall ever stating that the Neo was a super dog. Others may have, but I don't control what others believe. Bandog people however seem to believe that Neo's are some "super dog" because it's them who cross the Neo into their mixes, isn't it? So it's a little schizophrenic that you throw Neo's popularity into my face, if anything it should be the other way around. This board used to be very CO heavy, I'll give you that. These days it seems to be all about bandogs. But I don't think it will ever turn into a Shar fan forum. Ever. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] For me however, and MY desires...I like certain things for my lifestyle. You like the shar. Great. What's wrong with that. [/quote1332799469] Nothing. Which is why I provide a different perspective in these discussions where it mostly revolves around bully-derived "bandogs" of some sort. (Just look at the avatars and you know what I mean). I am doing this so people don't get the impression these are the only working dogs worth feeding. I advocate a very different paradigm altogether. It's definitely not for everyone, in fact Shars are hardly for anyone. But in certain settings, they rule. What's wrong with THAT? [u]Addendum:[/u] This thread is about the feasibility of dogs for survival in the wilderness. So what is wrong in proposing Shars, which are naturally protective and thrive in rural settings? Protection from wild animals, survival in rough environments, modest metabolism, that IS their very forte. As far as I am concerned, it's completely on topic. [quote1332799469=LeeRobinson] [quote]As for the hunting requirement, taking a big game hunting dog to an extended survival trip into the wilderness of today's real world will likely end you up in jail for poaching. Just saying.[/quote] Not in the scenario that resulted in me going "in wilderness survival mode." That would require law and order...and if that was the scenario...well, I would be home on the computer rebutting your nonsense on occasion...as I am now. ;) [/quote1332799469] Well, I like getting out of my box. I happen to like adventure. I don't wait for governments to collapse to explore America's great wilderness. And my computer is mostly for work, not so much for rebutting anyone's logorrhea. So I guess we're very different people. :)