• 1279

Are half check collars really better than full check chains?

There were a group of instructors actively encourage handlers to use half check collars with their dogs..seemingly whether they 'need' one or not (a very young lab puppy was given one, and her handler must have been about 10..the puppy was clearly confused and the handler continued to drag it around the arena).

The instructors there are trained by the British Institute of Professional Dog Trainers, so I assume they should know what they're talking about.

What do you think are they any better than other methods?

 ·   · 14 posts
  •  · 1106 friends
Comments (4)
  • In the past, I'd always used full check collars. Currently, I'm using a half check on my cocker spaniel. Harnesses and retractable leashes are a joke, as you can neither control nor correct the dog. The ten-year old had no business using a full choke collar on that puppy without having been trained herself to use it properly. Not meaning to attack or offend anyone, but I don't think there's ever a reason to use prongs (typically for pullers) or e-collars (the police use them on their dogs). A "trainer" who has to use them is not much of a trainer. It's of the utmost importance that dogs are trained and socialized from puppyhood (8 wks. +) to behave, though I do understand people sometimes acquire their dogs as adults, adults that already come with a set of poor behaviors (such as my cocker). I learned clear back in the 80s from watching Matthew Margolis (Uncle Matty) that all dogs can be taught, that prongs and e-collars are unnecessary - even with difficult dogs, and that there's never an excuse to hit your dog. Remember his commercials? "LOVE, PRAISE, and AFFECTION". I also learned from him why treat training is so bad (a no-brainer, really). I've had to email him a couple of times when I was working with aggressive dogs - one fear aggressive, the other dominant aggressive. Though he's basically retired now, he called me right back, very nice, and more than happy to advise. Yes, I've watched Cesar Milan..... I know many people like him, so I'll just leave it at 'his way is not Uncle Matty's way'. Bottom line, if applied properly, the full check and half check will not harm a dog's throat, and they're effective.
    • Suzannah,

      well said.  Your very last point is well taken.  As in most things in life it is not the tool we use but how we use it. The full and half check collars are great tools that are effective in correcting a trained dog.  It is therefore important that the dog understands the meaning of the collar.  It provides both an audible and tactile cue when a correction is necessary and the dog will learn this very quickly.

      • I'm in agreement. They both are tools. The tool is meaningless in the wrong person hands. But the tools are great when used correctly. It is the person that makes the tool effective or not.

      • I agree - if you use choke - make it full choke. The others are designed to make you feel good about your self and has nothing to do with correcting or controlling the dog.
        Info
        Category:
        Created:
        Updated:
        Featured Posts

        Molosserdogs.com at the Crossroads - Updated

        •  · 
        •  · admin
        Hello Molosser Fans, I think it is time to give you an update on this post that I made about a year ago. Firstly, I do enjoy providing a platform for us to share information about the molossers and I have made some friends through this website. We have, over the years connected many fans of our favorite breeds with each other and facilitated the sharing of information. Many of our members and visitors have seen the site change over the years from a mere gallery, to a forum and gallery, to a content management system, and now to the second iteration of a social network platform. This platform is where we have landed and at this time I do not see a reason to change platforms anymore.  So let

        San Antonio Vicious Dog Ordinance Bites

        •  · 
        •  · gsicard
        This article was written by Zandra Anderson, a lawyer in San Antonio, TX who specializes in pet law. The entire article is quoted below "It appears that a proposed vicious dog law in San Antonio could put nearly every dog that breathes in danger of being labeled vicious. San Antonio is considering one of the worst dog ordinances I have ever seen. Below is the proposed language–read it very carefully and keep in mind that the definition of enclosure includes your house and fenced yard. PLEASE–fax, call & email (addresses & numbers below)! Talking points are provided below. This is a bad law and can set precedent for other cities. The vote is this Thursday, 12/13/07, so you have t

        The Calgary Model

        •  · 
        •  · admin
        The Calgary Model   The animal control bylaw in Calgary, Alberta, Canada has been hailed by many as a HUGE success.  While other cities and provinces in Canada are banning breeds, Calgary is choosing education program and stronger enforcement.  What's the end result?  By all accounts, reports and statistics, the bylaw is working!   Not only that, the bylaw works so well and the results are so highly praised, Calgary is inspiring animal control officials outside of Canada to use the bylaw as a model for their own animal control ordinances.     The following is written by Dana Grove:   The bylaw officers in Calgary have taken a stand against breed banning, and responded to dog bite con

        Molosserdogs Future

        •  · 
        •  · gsicard
        I have seen the popularity and visits to many websites drop significantly. Theree was a belief that over time we would see static webcontent give way to smaller communities centered around particular interests where smaller groups of individual have commom interests. Sites like Facebook, pInterest, twitter, and new offerings from the big 3 (google, microsoft, Yahoo) mak it very difficult for smaller sites to popular again. It was partly that reason why i changed the format of MD to a community site to give members a site with features similar to fb but more community centric. Only the future will tell how we progress but i will keep molosserdogs.com running as long as i am able.

        Guide to Canine Cancer: Your Most Common Questions Answered

        Guide to Canine Cancer: Your Most Common Questions Answered From signs and symptoms to what to do if your dog's been diagnosed, get the important dog cancer information you need. Posted: May 29, 2014, 2 p.m. PST While too many dogs still get diagnosed with cancer each year, new research and treatments are helping increase the quality and quantity of life for dogs with the disease. Education also works as a powerful tool in preventing and dealing with canine cancer. In observance of Pet Cancer Awareness Month in May, the staff at The Veterinary Cancer Center in Norwalk, Conn., offers information on the disease that can benefit both you and the dogs in your life. Do Dogs Get Cancer? Answ

        Diffrent coats

        •  · 
        •  · desiree
        These 33 Dogs With The Most Unique Coats On Earth Took My Breath Away. My Favorite Is #7! These amazing dogs have such unusual colors and markings that once you see them, you’ll never be able to forget them. Some of these markings are a result of a rare genetic variations or conditions, but all of these dogs are undeniably beautiful. Of all the adorable and stunning dogs on the Internet, Reshareworthy.com collected and specifically chose the following 33 as the dogs with the most memorable and gorgeous markings!   This sweet husky has a natural little mask. This puppy also wears a mask! Everyone *nose* that this puppy has a lot of love to offer! This is Puck.

        Beware! Plants Poisonous to Dogs

        Beware! Plants Poisonous to Dogs Know which plants and foods are no-nos for your dog. By DC Editors | Posted: Mar 19, 2013, 3 p.m. EDT People are often surprised to learn that there are actually hundreds of plants potentially poisonous to dogs many of which could be in your home, or yard. The following is a list of some plants, trees, flowers, and foods that are poisonous to dogs: American bittersweet roots, leaves, berries Apple seeds, in large amounts Apricot seeds Autumn crocus -  Its active ingredient, colchicines, triggers an anti-metabolic effect that can cause rapidly dividing cells, shedding of the gastrointestinal tract, bloody diarrhea, and vomiting. Learn more>> Avocado l

        Science Diet’s “The Truth About Pet Food Ingredients”

        Science Diet’s “The Truth About Pet Food Ingredients” June 14, 2011 The Science Diet website now has a page titled “The Truth About Pet Food Ingredients Pet Food Myths Answered with Facts”.  Here’s what Science Diets says and of course I have some follow up… The Science Diet webpage starts off like this… “The TRUTH about pet nutrition.”  They go on to say “It’s important to understand what is myth or fact when making choices about what you feed your pet.”  I agree Science Diet, it IS important for pet parents to understand what is myth or fact when making choices about pet food.  So, let’s see what Science Diet’s myths and truths are… “Myth 1:  Corn is just filler.” “Fact:  A filler is an

        Training Preferences

        There are those that believe that everyone should not use any aversive when training a dog or doing behavioral modification.  They believe operant and classical condition is the only way to go. Others prefer to use force corrections. They use tools like check chains, pronged collars, e-collars, etc. There are also those that call themselves balance trainers. Instead of trying to train a dog or modify its behavior by force only or positive reinforcement only they believe nature teaches us that you need to have a balance between both in when dealing with dogs. I'm curious as to what other preference are? Where do you stand on this subject. I won't condemn anyone for their methods of choice
        Elite Guardian Presa - Presa Canario Puppies

        Elite Guardian Presa - Presa Canario Puppies

        CH. AKCM Aurelius has been bred to EGP PR' Princessa De Mercedes and to URO1 CH. AKCM Grace. The litters are confirmed and due in Feb.   EGP PR' Princessa De Mercedes    URO1 CH. AKCM Grace, CGC   CH. AKCM Aurelius