can PP dogs be reliable pets?
[quote1241113046=paw-paw]
Are PP reliable pets (with strangers) or not?
[/quote1241113046]
A dog that is properly trained in protection should be a fine pet.
It should be tolerant and unbiased with strangers unless given a reason.
The dog should be socialized well enough to differentiate between non-threatening, uncommon but non-threatening (such as drunk or handicapped people) and threatening behavior.
IMO the dog should no be trained to act only on a command as there might be a situation where you don't have a chance to give a command.
If training the dog only ends up makes it aggressive towards people then there is something wrong with the training - or at least for the purposes being asked about.
I've said it before and I'll say it again:
If your dog can't be trusted around strangers it's not really an effective PP dog if it is restrained and can't get to you to protect.
-
- · paw-paw
- ·
HI! I have experience with owning karst shepherds, a german shepherd and mix dogs. I also have friends with sarplaninacs (breeder) and sometimes work there so I have some experience with dogs... Now my dogs have all been good watchdogs and also exhibited protection instincts but I never trained any dog in PP before. (i was too young legally....). i never had any problems with them - none of them bit anyone or anything like that. I now have a karst shepherd mix and he has been thru dog school, but I never tought him protection work - he is 9 now, so there would be no point in starting teaching him now... Anyway, I am considering the option to train my next dog (I am not sure of the breed yet) as a PP dog. But I must admit I am a bit scared that the PP training will make the dog aggressive. Now I was reading on the net a lot and i find contradictory information... Some say that PP dogs can be trusted to attack only on command and I know that is the way it should be. But there are also some who say that this dogs can attack without command also - and that is of course something that I do not want. Now, I will be living in the middle of nowhere soon so I always want to have a dog that will be able to defend me and my property, but at the same time a dog, that I would be able to take with me anywhere I go... With sarplaninacs I have experience that yes, they are managable but you have to constantly be on guard as to what they are doing when interacting with strangers (people and dogs) - is it the same with PP dogs or not? What breeds are suitable as PP dogs. I know some are suitable as guard dogs, but I am looking for a PP dog (cause breeds we have here are naturally protective of their homes anyway) - that will obey commands. I hope you know what I am asking...Please, I know there are some experienced members on this forum, I want a nonbiased opinion on this. Are PP reliable pets (with strangers) or not? Cause I know there are also a lot of internet sites selling trained PP dogs and they all claim they can be great pets, but is this true or do they just want to sell? THX -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote1241113046=paw-paw] Are PP reliable pets (with strangers) or not? [/quote1241113046] A dog that is properly trained in protection should be a fine pet. It should be tolerant and unbiased with strangers unless given a reason. The dog should be socialized well enough to differentiate between non-threatening, uncommon but non-threatening (such as drunk or handicapped people) and threatening behavior. IMO the dog should no be trained to act only on a command as there might be a situation where you don't have a chance to give a command. If training the dog only ends up makes it aggressive towards people then there is something wrong with the training - or at least for the purposes being asked about. I've said it before and I'll say it again: If your dog can't be trusted around strangers it's not really an effective PP dog if it is restrained and can't get to you to protect. -
- · paw-paw
- ·
THX for the quick respnse :) So if properly trained, PP dogs can be "normal" pets than? Just one more question...What do you think of the fact that some are selling trained PP dogs already? I don't know personally how I feel about it (as said before - I don't have experience with PP training) but would those dogs even obey their new master? I think I would rather train my dog myself (with a good instructor of course) but than there is one more worry for me... I know that selling PP dogs has become a profitable industry for some... I am just wandering...Does it happen often that a particular dog doesn't do well in training and just becomes aggressive and uncontrolable despite trainers best efforts? Cause I imagine that a lot of it has to do with genetics also... The reason I am asking is because if I get a dog and train at as a PP dog and than discover it has weak nerves and becomes uncontrolable - well I am very affraid of this, to tell you the truth...Cause I just can't imagine what I would do... So does this happen or not? Cause than if you are buying an already trained dog than you can see its character and you see that it isn't damaged... So in how many cases does it happen that a dog is not for that job? Cause I know that for example when trainig dogs for the blind or police, military (OK, I know that their training is very different) etc there are some % of dogs that fail in that training and are given away as pets. And that is even tho they have their own breeding kennels so are breeding from succesful dogs only. But with failed PP dogs - what happens to them...? -
- · unknown
- ·
A properly trained PP should be a "Better" than the average pet dog. PP is about training & control....it is not about bitting. The Bite is the reward for properly executing the command. Obedient dogs are a pleasure to own. You to big concers are getting a mentally stable dog and finding a qualified helper that will not ruin you dog. Good luck -
- · unknown
- ·
There's very few situations where I agree with buying a dog that's already trained in bitework. Law enforcement is an obvious one. Another is if the dog is going to be used only as a sport dog or will be retired and used for breeding programs or just as a house pet. I know that there are trainers out there who offer finished dogs in PP work but I will not buy a dog like this nor do I necessarily advocate. I don't mind having some ground work done, but not a "finished" dog for PP. Not only are the prices typically exorbitantly higher. Also, I think that a PP dog should be just that: a personal protector. Nobody else knows exactly what you want out of your dog and I think tha tgoing through personal protection training together is a great bonding experience for the human/dog relationship. I have seen dogs that were trained in lower to intermediate levels of PP work and then sold or rehomed who did fine adjusting to protecting a new owner. It just is not my personal recommendation. -
- · Carlos1122
- ·
I had a Rottweiler female that had bitten a few times for little or no reason she was 4.5 years old when I had her do bitework after that she lived another 4.5 years never bit anyone else she realized they actually had to ask for a bite made her much more stable in the long run. -
- · unknown
- ·
Do you think say an Scott American Bulldog could be a loyal, and stable family pet as well as a good dog to train for PP ? I dont want a dog thats going to jump and go for people for no reason afterall, wonder if there prey drive will lead to this ? -
- · unknown
- ·
Am Bulls are definitely capable of being loyal family guardians trained in PP. As for the jumping and prey drive, that is all on you as the handler/trainer/owner, you can teach a dog not to jump, you can redirect its prey drive into something productive (work/training) or non destructive (games, toys etc.) Don't get too caught up in "whats the BEST breed" - a great deal of how your dog behaves and acts is going to come down to how much time you are willing to put into it, and the quality of training you provide it with. Of course certain breeds do show a more natural tendency towards certain things like guarding - however most molossers fall into this category. Concentrate more on finding a good breeder and a good trainer and educating yourself on the kinds of things you will need to provide for the dog to ensure a desirable outcome for both of you. -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote1258043482=Jrouble] Am Bulls are definitely capable of being loyal family guardians trained in PP. As for the jumping and prey drive, that is all on you as the handler/trainer/owner, you can teach a dog not to jump, you can redirect its prey drive into something productive (work/training) or non destructive (games, toys etc.) Don't get too caught up in "whats the BEST breed" - a great deal of how your dog behaves and acts is going to come down to how much time you are willing to put into it, and the quality of training you provide it with. Of course certain breeds do show a more natural tendency towards certain things like guarding - however most molossers fall into this category. Concentrate more on finding a good breeder and a good trainer and educating yourself on the kinds of things you will need to provide for the dog to ensure a desirable outcome for both of you. [/quote1258043482] Good post thankyou, and some good points about its down the owner, and redirecting the dogs prey drive and training it. Then of course this then correlates into what you put into the dog in time, training, love and effection is what results you get out of it. While also thankyou for reminding how important it is to find a good breeder :) I also thought the American Bulldog was one of the best allround breeds around, for its variety of wokring traits, from agility and imense power, to its gaurding insticts. To also being very loyal dogs, with a stable tempermant if brought up correctly. -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote1258047960=Adam_CC] [quote1258043482=Jrouble] Am Bulls are definitely capable of being loyal family guardians trained in PP. As for the jumping and prey drive, that is all on you as the handler/trainer/owner, you can teach a dog not to jump, you can redirect its prey drive into something productive (work/training) or non destructive (games, toys etc.) Don't get too caught up in "whats the BEST breed" - a great deal of how your dog behaves and acts is going to come down to how much time you are willing to put into it, and the quality of training you provide it with. Of course certain breeds do show a more natural tendency towards certain things like guarding - however most molossers fall into this category. Concentrate more on finding a good breeder and a good trainer and educating yourself on the kinds of things you will need to provide for the dog to ensure a desirable outcome for both of you. [/quote1258043482] Good post thankyou, and some good points about its down the owner, and redirecting the dogs prey drive and training it. Then of course this then correlates into what you put into the dog in time, training, love and effection is what results you get out of it. While also thankyou for reminding how important it is to find a good breeder :) I also thought the American Bulldog was one of the best allround breeds around, for its variety of wokring traits, from agility and imense power, to its gaurding insticts. To also being very loyal dogs, with a stable tempermant if brought up correctly. [/quote1258047960] You just answered your own question then, if those above traits in your last sentence are what you are looking for in a dog, you have undoubtedly hit the nail on the head, as an AmBull will cover all of those bases. You just have to hold up your end of the bargain as a good trainer/owner and find yourself a pup or dog from a good breeding that you think is going to live up to your expectations. I wish you well on your search :)