• 622

goats with dogs?

drive to an area that has boar - nothing particularly sporting about goat hunting
14
10
1
11
15

Replies (50)

    • can you or do people or have you ever heard of people hunting goats or feral goats with dogs? like using them as catch dogs on goats? if so is it legal in southern california? reason I ask is I have always wanted to hunt with my dogs, using them as catch dogs, but there is nothing in my area for them to catch, no hogs. I have come across some feral goats when i go hiking with my dogs on public land, I was wondering if it would be legal to hunt them with my dogs. if so, what are the dangers to my dogs?
          • I've known people to do it, not very sporting, goats can't put up much of a fight and aren't even that fast. What they are good at is climbing and jumping around on rocks, hunting them in rough rocky and hilly country could prove a challenge.
            • I found this posted on another forum back in 2001. [quote]Assembly Bill 342 (AB 342), sponsored by Democratic Assemblyman Paul Koretz, would make it illegal for any dog to pursue or kill a mammal. The U.S. Sportsmen's Alliance (USSA) say it would ban bear hunting, fox hunting, rabbit hunting, raccoon hunting and more.[/quote] It does not talk about goat - but I am sure the goat lobby would not allow it. I don't think you can even kill flies or ants in CA anymore. When I was growing up - our goats were very safe from dogs and could easily knock a dog off a rock. They are quite surefooted - and some of the big Billys can be real nasty if challenged. You may want to check into some of the places that offer hunting (is there any left in CA?) and see if the allow dogs.
              • drive to an area that has boar - nothing particularly sporting about goat hunting
                • What I find odd as well is the rarity of hunting deer with dogs? It seems really taboo or something and I'm wondering why? I could definitely see myself getting into it. Seems we (humans) used to get into it in a big way-
                  • i found a hunting ranch that happens to be very close that i can do some hog hunting on. I am thinking of giving it a shot. but first i need to turn my dogs into hog dogs. Now I am thinking since people say goats would be so easy, it may be a good way for my dogs to "get their feet wet" and experience the hunt etc.
                    • Yeah I say do it. If those are the dogs in your avatar I would suggest stripping a fair bit of weight off them, but after that you should be good to go.
                      • Don't do it mate, using dogs on goats is borderline disgusting. Its not much different to letting them loose on sheep. We hunted feral goats on my Granddads farm when I was a kid, we used crossbows. If my Grandad had caught us using dogs he probably would have killed us!
                        • [quote1294056120=Tonedog] What I find odd as well is the rarity of hunting deer with dogs? It seems really taboo or something and I'm wondering why? I could definitely see myself getting into it. Seems we (humans) used to get into it in a big way- [/quote1294056120] Seeing as all Deer are owned by the Queen in the UK over here (along with Swans) that probably has something to do with it. I live in an area that has a huge population of Deer and from what I understand it's the local authority that are responsible for humainly culling them when they reach high numbers. Most of the deer where I live are tagged, so if one goes missing someone gets to know about it ;) Apparently, it goes back to medieval times and something to do with Henry VIII and poaching. And seeing as Australia is part of the commonweath, that's probably why it isn't common place anymore ;)
                          • Its illegal in most he U.S to use dogs. By the way I dont think people used dogs to bring down deer. Its more like blood tracking when your shot doesnt bring it down or people and dogs flushing towards your stand. Deer can kill dogs and if they dont fight, which is possible with a buck in rut, a dogs has no chance of catching a deer. Coyotes take care of fawns, sick, and injured. Wouldnt you be better served by finding some hog people and learning that way, since there are plenty of hog people around the U.S in the south.
                            • People most certainly used to use dogs to bring down deer, and it is still done but very very rarely and it's like there's a taboo around it. In general I think hunting with dogs is the most natural way to hunt, the only way to hunt that genuinely tests the quarry, good specimens utilise their god given qualities and escape, lesser specimens make mistakes and fall prey to the dogs, and it's all very natural and lovely. It's a contest the prey animals understand, a sport they can actually participate in and be good at. Frankly I don't agree with shooting things, with a gun, crossbow or otherwise. That's unnatural, and it doesn't matter how good a deer or a boar is, they can all equally come undone from a bullet to the head. If it was up to me hunting with dogs would be the only hunting that's legal. This actually was the case in the past. Killing a fox by way other than by dog used to be known as "vulpicide", and I think this makes perfect sense. Give the prey animal a chance to earn it's freedom and pass on it's genes. Anything less is a travesty against nature.
                              • Tonedog you obviously havent seen the amount of deer in the U.S. They are a nuisance as it is on the East coast bar the south, due to the number of "Urbanites and Suburbanites" and foreigners who dont hunt and don't want predatory animals around like coyotes and such that help control the population. If you can post a video of a white tail getting taken down by a dog or dogs alone then you get prize of the century. Not a fawn or sick deer either, a healthy buck or doe. I say this because I don't believe it can happen w/o extraordinary circumstances. People lose good hunting dogs every year that like to "run trash" and never catch its quarry. Not to make fun of you but I am still chuckling about the "unnaturalness" of shooting prey animals :) Being human and having "gooder" brains than monkeys gives us the ability to "shoot" things which is quite natural for a human. :) And prey animals dont participate in a sport, they run for their lives!
                                • Well I'm more pissed off about the fact using dogs is seen as wrong, than the fact using guns is seen as right. Go ahead and shoot deer, but don't then tell me I can't catch them with dogs. When you do that it makes me start thinking about it, and when I think about it I notice how much worse shooting them is. If americans in the north east were consistently hunting deer with dogs you wouldn't have that problem, AND you could be sure the surviving population were all good quality animals with natural predator evading capabilities. As for dogs being unable to bring down deer, historically it was well known that deer are an easier fight than boars, even full grown stags. And stags of species that are bigger and more imposing than white tails. They're harder to run down, easier to pull down. This also mirrored with wild predators like cougars that can take down deers of all kind, even elk, while avoiding adult wild hogs. While it is rare I do know of people who hunt deer with dogs that actually take them down. Staghounds and deerhounds do it in australia and countless types of lurchers and long dogs were doing in england until very recently. On the bull arab website it's mentioned that bull arabs have been used to catch brumbies (wild horses) and a similar mongrel dog regularly takes down sambar deer 1 on 1. Sambar are more serious than white tails. For that matter people catch scrub cattle with dogs, scrub cattle are obviously about 10 times more dangerous than any deer. A dog needs speed to catch a deer more than anything, hence the shape of deerhounds compared to the shape of boar dogs and bull dogs.
                                  • I think its a brilliant idea to use dogs to hunt anything! But im pretty sure we can't use dogs legally in the U.S for deer. Once more I think when people could it was to blood track and flush towards hunters which isn't very sporting. Amish like to do that I hear, in the U.S, but they use their kids instead of dogs lol And I have read that deer and stag hounds can do it, but now aren't the deer smaller in northern Europe than what we have here in the Americas w/ the exception of Mule Deer? But then again I have never seen or met an actuall deer/stag hound or lurcher/bull arab for that matter. Regardless if you could dig up a vid or make one that would be priceless! Simply because I don't think dogs can do it. Least ways I don't believe they can run a deer down and take it. Interesting debate regardless thanks for the exchange!
                                    • There used to be heaps of videos of sighthounds killing deer on uk hunting sites like thehuntinglife.com but since it became illegal they're not there anymore. It is hard to find which is what I'm talking about, but I don't think it has anything to do with deer being hard for dogs to catch or kill just rather that it's taboo and/or illegal. Everything I've heard suggests they're fairly easy to kill, and this is something I've gone out of my way to learn a lot about. Here's someone complaining about their border collie cross killing deers- [URL]http://freerepublic.com/focus/f-chat/2156957/posts[/URL] What I've learned studying deer in general (I'm obsessed with deer for some reason ever since I discovered I lived in one of the deer hot spots in australia) is that they're actually pretty easy for predators to kill, they're runners more than fighters, rarely using their antlers against predators. [QUOTE]And I have read that deer and stag hounds can do it, but now aren't the deer smaller in northern Europe than what we have here in the Americas w/ the exception of Mule Deer? [/QUOTE] No. Some of the deer known to be caught and killed by dogs are sambar and red deer, which both weigh around 500 and up to 1000 lbs on rare occasions, while white tails weigh around 350 lbs.
                                      • The idea that humans using weapons is 'unnatural' is maybe the funniest thing I have ever read on the net!!! I don't know whether I am a hypocrite, but I have gone pig hunting with dogs before and never saw a moral issue with it. But the idea of letting dogs loose on deer, sheep or goats just turns my stomach.
                                        • Here's some greyhounds taking an impala in south africa, not a deer but actually the general consensus is that antelope are tougher than deer.
                                          • [quote1294097874=soldiermonkey] The idea that humans using weapons is 'unnatural' is maybe the funniest thing I have ever read on the net!!! I don't know whether I am a hypocrite, but I have gone pig hunting with dogs before and never saw a moral issue with it. But the idea of letting dogs loose on deer, sheep or goats just turns my stomach. [/quote1294097874] I would say that yeah you are a bit of a hypocrite, but you can't help the way you feel. It has no such effect on me. Sheep yes, because they have evolved with LGDs and naturally are unable to look after themselves, but deer and wild goats for that matter should be able to evade dogs if they are good representatives of their respective species. It's a natural thing that if they can't get away from a dog they should be killed and subseqently eaten by said dog. Maybe I'm a hypocrite too because seeing something get shot turns my stomach. Especially non-prey animals like lions and stuff like that, but even deer leaves me feeling like "well... that wasn't really fair". I actually hate animal cruelty in general, but I don't classify herbivores being hunted by dogs as animal cruelty. It's extremely natural. Does viewing predator/prey interaction in general turn your stomach? Or just when the predator is a domestic dog?
                                            • Thats a good question about predators, and the answer is that no, it doesnt worry me at all. Which I agree is an odd thing. I also agree that killing non-prey animals for sport is just not a great thing. However, I only agree in using dogs where that is the most effective method available. Since I was successfully hunting goat at 10 without them, I believe using dogs on goats is both unnecessary and cruel
                                              • SooOoOOO.........should i go for the goats with my dogs to gain them some hunting experience? and yes it will be the dogs in my photo, but not the one with the white face. he does not have a very high prey drive etc. and would not be suited for catching at all.
                                                • If I was you I'd be taking my dogs out hunting whatever all the time. Infact if I was me I'd be doing that, and I am doing that. Actually fighting around with the pig or goat or whatever will come pretty naturally to your pitbulls, you should be nurturing their "outdoorsmanship" and bush smarts and their noses and etc, getting their feet hard and also yeah getting them in shape. Go out chasing rabbits and squirrels and turkeys and whatever, goats as well if they're there. That's just my opinion. In my opinion getting dogs out there hunting things is all good.
                                                    • thank you tonedog for the replies as you really seem to be the only one bothering answering my questions. and for everyones information there is a deer with dogs thread like 2 posts below this one.
                                                      • While Tonedog might be the only one giving you the answers you want, that doesn't actually mean no one else here has expressed an opinion... lol
                                                        • Around here the DEM will catch you trying to run dogs on wild life and WILL take your dogs.
                                                          • Yes, god forbid dogs be dogs. Instead we're supposed to put them in little chain link fence dog parks which are supposed to be "fun" for them. Lol. The people making the rules of society know nothing about dogs at best, outright hate them and aim to insult them at worst. Dogs yearn to be out in the wilderness smelling animals, seeing animals and chasing animals. Any dog not being given the opportunity to do this is being mistreated in my eyes. I've seen how much they enjoy it and how much they come alive, I really believe it's nothing short of cruelty to deprive them of this lifestyle.
                                                            • Hunting Goats with pit bulls is bull crap stupidity unless you intend to make some really bad soup.
                                                              • I think if his dogs can catch wild goats they deserve to have them and eat them. To be honest I don't think he'll catch any, but I'm sure his dogs will have a ball trying.
                                                                • I am not against the hunt. I'm against sport killing.
                                                                  • i am against sport killing too. If I did get a goat I would eat it. Its used in a lot of mexican food I believe. for the record, if i lived in an area such as texas, with a huge overpopulation of pig, no season or limit, i would be hunting hogs every weekend. but its not the case in the deserts of southern california I want to hunt with my dogs. my dogs would be best suited as a catch dog. therefore it would make most sense to hunt hogs. there are no hogs where I live. in order to get the experience of hog hunting with my dogs for both me and my dogs I am looking at paying money to hunt on a ranch. that being said I must now train my dogs to catch hogs. how do you train dogs to catch hogs with no hogs? I dont know, maybe catching another animal is a good idea, and thats how the whole goat thing came up. I got opinions, i than asked another question and was ignored by all but tonedog as the thread went on about deer with dogs. I dont mind, i just wanted some opinions on my 2nd question which is........how can i prepare my dogs to hunt hogs? maybe catching goats is a good idea?
                                                                    • I have been pig hunting a hundred times with a shit load of different dogs. I have to ask, are you calling those dogs in your avatar catch dogs? I swear to God, pig hunting must be very different where you are from if they are.... they would die the first day out here in Aus. Too short, too fat, too slow.... sorry mate, I am sure they are fantastic pets.
                                                                      • you wouldnt be the first person to tell me something similiar too that. although you have never seen my dogs in person and are basing that off a tiny picture you can see. i have also had people who just hear the breed of my dog and say the same thing, although i do agree with you on the one with the white face gets tired fast, but the other 2 can go all day. my biggest one is pretty athletic for his size. heres a video of them screwing around..it doesnt show much but I take them out hiking regularly and I believe they could do it. this video doesnt really show much at all but its the only one i have. i put it on here before IMO my dogs are still workable. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdpRpapzxhU
                                                                        • "Photobucket" "Photobucket" "Photobucket" a few pics from different angles that may change your mind
                                                                            • Well I apologise if you think I was bashing your dogs, that wasn't the intention... and yes, I agree with you that the pigs in those video's are very small, or is that the size of them in the USA? I don't think saying that your dogs aren't suited to a particular task is really that bad? Its just that your dogs wouldn't fit in with any of the crews I have seen pigging. They are too slow to bail, and too small to lug.
                                                                              • Don't do it man. It's a good way to get fined and it's damned messy. It might even make your dogs over confident and make them careless around wild pigs. IMO it would be best to start them out slowly. Make sure that they have vest and that you are with experienced hog dogs and hunter.
                                                                                • yeah i plan on getting them vests and neck protection. how can i start them out slowly?
                                                                                  • i had a question regarding stamina and catch dogs. granted the dog must have some stamina, but if you use bay dogs to bay the hog, and than walk up with your catch dog and let him off leash to catch, it seems to me the dog is not going to need nearly as much stamina as say for example the bay dogs, as the bay dogs are doing all the finding, running, and baying, the catch dog is just simply catching. Therefore couldnt any large powerfull dog be used for catching?
                                                                                    • [quote1297584805=cawkazn] Therefore couldnt any large powerfull dog be used for catching? [/quote1297584805] Its not really a matter of walking up... both you and your dogs will be doing it very tough (mostly you!!) its sweaty hard work. The luggers (u call them catch dogs, must be a local term) generally run free with the bailers, they just arrive later to the action. In the crews I have gone out with, bullmastiff x great danes are very popular for the heavy work... the girls are usually 40-50 kilos and the boys from 50-60 kilos, but really quite lean. In pounds they would between 100-140 pounds I suppose. I attached a photo of Xena, she is owned by a kennel called O'Halloran hounds and is used both in the hunt and as a home guard. She is the result of generations of successful pig dog breeding and is the typical bullmastiif x greatdane mix. She is a 50 kg bitch. Hopefully I will get a couple of her pups one day, I really like her![br][img:width=448&height=336]{e_FILE}public/1297586317_6309_FT77305_xena1.jpg">
                                                                                      • Soldiermonkey they do it a little different in the states. In australia we generally have allrounders, the different dogs in a pack might be a little this way or that way inclined, more specialised for lugging, more specialised for finding, the odd bailer, but all of them are usually expected to do everything, like you say be loose running free with the other dogs the whole time. In the states they often have really highly specialised catch dogs or luggers which are literally walked up to a bailed pig on a lead and set loose on it. After the bailers/bay dogs/hounds have done all the searching, trailing, chasing, baying it up, etc. No one much does that in australia. As you note our dogs run free with the finders whether they are finders themselves or not and therefore typically need a bit of leg and stamina. I'd say specialised catchdogs still need some stamina, they need to be fit to wrestle around with the boar but yeah they don't need a particularly efficient energy-conserving stride or anything like that. A pure apbt is fine as a specialised catch dog, they're not too small to lug. Maybe not ideal for certain conditions where they can be swung around and bashed into trees but they'll generally do very well as luggers. The odd person in australia does use a pure apbt. Just a couple of pics of pure apbt aussie pig dogs-
                                                                                        • Walking up to a bailed pig with a dog on a leash? That sounds as much like genuine hunting as the pheasant shoots the royalty types wank around with
                                                                                          • Yeah I don't really get it, but I suppose it's just a different approach to the same thing. Kind of like how in american football they have all these highly specialised positions, while in rugby the positions are loosely defined and everyone is able to do everything. All the same things are taking place in the american style of hunting, it's just that where we hybridise all types to get dogs that will do it all, they use different types for different parts of the hunt. We'll splash a bit of bulldog or bullterrier into our hybrids to get lugging ability, they'll have a bulldog or bullterrier in their pack to lug only. I personally prefer an allrounder, it feels like a more complete animal if it can find, run down and lug up the boar by itself. But that isn't to say it's a better lugger than a specialised catch dog, typically it won't be because a jack of all trades is a master of none. By only having to worry about the lugging up part specialised catch dogs can afford to be more acutely adapted to that part only.
                                                                                            • Fair enuff, specialising seems a very common approach for them. I have worked with plenty of American soldiers, and they are so highly specialised, they become almost useless in areas we consider basic soldiering. But I assume that they are FANTASTIC at the one thing they are employed to do. Hey, if it works for em, why not i guess....
                                                                                              • [quote1297652644=soldiermonkey] [quote1297584805=cawkazn] Therefore couldnt any large powerfull dog be used for catching? [/quote1297584805] Its not really a matter of walking up... both you and your dogs will be doing it very tough (mostly you!!) its sweaty hard work. The luggers (u call them catch dogs, must be a local term) generally run free with the bailers, they just arrive later to the action. In the crews I have gone out with, bullmastiff x great danes are very popular for the heavy work... the girls are usually 40-50 kilos and the boys from 50-60 kilos, but really quite lean. In pounds they would between 100-140 pounds I suppose. I attached a photo of Xena, she is owned by a kennel called O'Halloran hounds and is used both in the hunt and as a home guard. She is the result of generations of successful pig dog breeding and is the typical bullmastiif x greatdane mix. She is a 50 kg bitch. Hopefully I will get a couple of her pups one day, I really like her![br][img:width=448&height=336]{e_FILE}public/1297586317_6309_FT77305_xena1.jpg"> [/quote1297652644] i like the great dane alot, I like the great dane outcrossed to mastiff etc. I think it pretty much produces what the old great danes were and what great danes should be. Not what most of them are today, well at least here in the states.
                                                                                                • Just bumping this back up over all that chinese spam.
                                                                                                  • Yeah I agree, she does seem like an old school dane.... for me, she represents a really good balance of power, speed and stamina.
                                                                                                    • Another nice dane/bullmastiff courtesy of boardogs.com-
                                                                                                      • i love that site, i often go back there to check what crazy mix has been done next!
                                                                                                        Login or Join to comment.

                                                                                                        cawkazn
                                                                                                        •  ·  Moderator
                                                                                                        • D

                                                                                                          1

                                                                                                          A

                                                                                                          84 friends
                                                                                                        • M

                                                                                                          8 followers
                                                                                                        • 13393 views

                                                                                                        Partaken

                                                                                                        The Campeiro Bulldog
                                                                                                        Feeding a Raw Diet
                                                                                                        Pics of fila X apbt
                                                                                                        why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
                                                                                                        American Bully
                                                                                                        question about socialization with a fila
                                                                                                        Am I Asking For Too Much...?
                                                                                                        Serbian defense dog