• 622

rotweiler versus SAB

Hi Carlos,

 

I have red your profile and saw that you have a lot of experience with dogs specialy rotweilers.

 

Now you own a SAB, can you tell me why you make the change, the diffrences between them?

 

Did you go into another direction because the rotweiler is almost ruind only good for shows?

 

In Holland i barely see a good rotweiler, too bad because it is a wonderful breed.

 

Welcome to the site and hope you want to share a little of your experiences.

 

Greetings Dees

Replies (6)

    • Hi Carlos,

       

      I have red your profile and saw that you have a lot of experience with dogs specialy rotweilers.

       

      Now you own a SAB, can you tell me why you make the change, the diffrences between them?

       

      Did you go into another direction because the rotweiler is almost ruind only good for shows?

       

      In Holland i barely see a good rotweiler, too bad because it is a wonderful breed.

       

      Welcome to the site and hope you want to share a little of your experiences.

       

      Greetings Dees

      • Des I have a St.Miguel cattle dog (Cao de Fila de Sao Miguel)(Azores cattle dog) I'm sure they were part of the SAB  concidering the Portugees settlers that were in South African from the begining, also a founder of the Brazilian Fila and probably part of the St.Johns dog they are always brindle and are smaller than both breeds because it has been used as a cattle dog/livestock guardian/hunting dog/guard dog for more than 500 years they were the fences to keep cattle on the property and away from your crops and the neigbours crops, protection from pirates.I think they are the best all around farm dogs with one of the longest uniturupted histories of a all around do anything farm dog where most other breeds are just gaurdians or just herders or hunters. I spent more than a year looking at breeds and this is the perfect breed for me it has a longer coat than a boxer or pit so can handle Canadian winters better mine will go into ice water they haven't been ruined by breeders or show people because they are unknown nothing wreaks a breed faster than popularity like the Rottwieler there are good Rotts out there just hard to find I found the nerves much better with the Azores cattle dog and they are slightly smaller then a proper Rott much smaller than the oversized Rotts, they are still used as police dogs in Portugal and farm dogs I got mine from a working cattle ranch in Canada one of only three breeders in North America. They are my breed for life they are one of the best allaround do anything go anywhere dogs they range from 19-24 inches and weight 50-85pounds will fit in any car and are more than big enough to take care of business. They are a very strong willed dog that needs plenty of socializiing very obiedent but need a firm hand to raise them right.

        • From all I've seen and heard boerboels on average are way more ruined than rotts. Saying that, best vs best I consider the boerboel a better dog. But yeah thinking of the bb as an "unruined" alternative to the rott is sorely mistaken IMO. Most boerboel breeders are producing big useless meat bags these days. Unhealthy immobile monstrosities.

          • I spent a LOT of time researching Rott's in Australia recently, before I decided to stick with the bandogs. I did find a few really nice examples, physically speaking, but I just didn't think they were sharp enough.

             

            I go away a few times a year, and I prefer having a really switched on dog looking after things for me.

            •  

              From all I've seen and heard boerboels on average are way more ruined than rotts. Saying that, best vs best I consider the boerboel a better dog. But yeah thinking of the bb as an "unruined" alternative to the rott is sorely mistaken IMO. Most boerboel breeders are producing big useless meat bags these days. Unhealthy immobile monstrosities.

               Although Sadly I agree whole heartedly with this statement as there are those in our society with the mentality that bigger is better and care nothing about what the breed was designed/intended to do and the breeders that are looking to make that profit.  But with that said having been a part of this breed for the past 2 years, there are still a few good breeders that strive to produce a good funcitionaly "working" Boerboel and the results are IMO, quite impressive.  Potential Boerboel buyers just have to be educated and know the "working" qualities that they are looking for. 

              •  

                From all I've seen and heard boerboels on average are way more ruined than rotts. Saying that, best vs best I consider the boerboel a better dog. But yeah thinking of the bb as an "unruined" alternative to the rott is sorely mistaken IMO. Most boerboel breeders are producing big useless meat bags these days. Unhealthy immobile monstrosities.

                 Hi Tonedog,

                I have diferent oppinion on this.

                Yes there are ruind sab, mostly outside south Afica, but in tis country of origin they do not speak (from what I know at least) for working lines sab.

                On the other side, lots of DECATES now in Rotties country of origin on where ever, not only they have separate working non working lines (WHEN YOU SEE THAT THE BREED IS ALREADY DESTROYED, my oppinion) but even within working lines, seems to be like lottary ticket nowadays to get a REAL DOG, with full insticts, courage, determination, living only to serve and guard.

                In south Africa mentioning the term Boerboel you mean all as above.

                I own a SAB, I have seen many "shap" Rotties, not they are all so bad, but even for the best of them, THERE IS NOTHING TO COMPARE with the Boerboel.

                15 days ago, I also bought a Caucasian Ovcharka puppy and looks promising to me.

                The only breeds I place next to these 2 breeds guarding wise specifically (not as general working wise) is fila brazileiro and presa canario.

                I could name few more close to thm, but for sure the average Rotty would not fit to my list as equal one.

                This is just my perspective of course.

                Login or Join to comment.

                desiree
                •  ·  Administrator
                • M

                  F

                  P

                  D

                  1604 friends
                • D

                  J

                  C

                  1412 followers
                • 10336 views
                • 1 votes

                Partaken

                The Campeiro Bulldog
                Feeding a Raw Diet
                Pics of fila X apbt
                why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
                American Bully
                question about socialization with a fila
                Am I Asking For Too Much...?
                Serbian defense dog