• 560

Spaying...

I've tried every which way to post to this one and cannot :( http://molosserdogs.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?15244

Replies (19)

    • Took my soon to be 16 weeks female to the vet for her last set of shots. During the conversation, the vet mentioned to make sure to bring her in for spaying before she turns 6 months od or before her first heat. He said that will reduce her risk for breast cancer by 90%. I told him I wanted to wait until she had two heats and is around 18 months old befor doing so, to make sure she is fully developed physicaly and mentally. His answer was that spaying a female early does not affect her temperament or physic like it does for males. Does anyone has experience with this? Thanks
      • I've actually heard it can have the opposite effect on females that it has on males, making them produce more testosterone and making them more masculine in nature and muscular in physiology. Could be BS, but was convincing when I was hearing about it.
        • I can't believe that some veterinarians still peddle this crap to their clients. 90% reduction in the chance of breast cancer eh? Really, why not 100%, or 75% or 50%. If I were you I would find another vet immediately. There are many threads on here about the benefits and when to spay and neuter but if a vet ever told me to "make sure I bring my dog in for spay or neuter" I would never go back to that practice. Basically, it is none of their business if and when you alter your dog.
          • It is vet's job to suggest spay and neuter, mostly to prevent unwanted litters, and therefore dogs ending up in shelters. There are a lot of careless people out there, their female dog gets pregnant, and they often will drop entire litters off at the nearest shelter. Vets use health benefits (whatever they can think of) to try to pursuade people to do early spay/neuter. A lot of vets probably believe what they preach, and a lot of pet owners assume everything the vet says is true. They will happily neuter a 4 month old mastiff male, regardless of the health and development consequences. I spayed my EB at around 6mths, and she did develop hypothyroidism. She could have gotten that anyway, but I've read somewhere that early spaying can do that. Here's a link http://www.caninesports.com/SpayNeuter.html Another thing I don't listen to vets about, is food. They will try to poison dogs on that crap they sell and profit on. So, I would just say ya ya, i'll get to it and ignore their attempts to do the operation.
            • I disagree - the vets job is to administer whatever is best for your dog based on an ailment or prescribed treatment. It is not their job to control breeding or suggest spay and neuter. They are to discharge their profession by taking care of the animal that is brought to them. It is the owner who must decide if they want to spay or neuter their dog. Like I said, if a vet ever suggest it to me - they have lost me as a client. That is just how I see things and is in now way a representation of anyone else opinion. I will not surrender my free exercise of pet ownership to a pawn of the industry. I do respect vets and one of my best friends is indeed a vet. However, when I take a dog to the vet it is my money that is being spent - so that is where there influence ends. If they feel so strongly about spay / neuter they should do it for free. :)
              • Agree with gary on that issue, when vets suggest getting my dogs desexed I feel like suggesting they cut their own nuts off. I really don't feel like it's their business to push their political agendas on people, right or wrong.
                • Here are the facts. Yes, the risk of mammary tumors increases with each heat. Mammary tumors do have estrogen receptors. The reason the risk reduction is not 100% is because there is still mammary tissue, same as in males (yes, males can have mammary tumors as well). It is the Vets job to suggest these things. Unfortunately, none really give you all of the facts (I believe because they themselves do not know). My Vet asks if this is a breeding animal before suggesting anything. Personally, I feel this is a better approach. However, suggesting is not bad, it is the misinformation and pressure that are. If a Vet suggests it and I say no, then we move on. If they push, then find another Vet. A Vet can suggest putting a dog on a diet as well, but they can't force you to. Either way, they do have the dog's best interest at heart, but maybe not in mind though, lol. http://www.naiaonline.org/pdfs/longtermhealtheffectsofspayneuterindogs.pdf *There is also suspicion of not only osteosarcoma increase in altered dogs, but increased joint issues (torn CCL, etc.)
                  • I had a male dog that was not neutered and everyone in LA was freaking out when they saw him...lol Many would say he will have prostate cancer at a young age, etc... Well he lived an extremly healthy life until he died at the age of 16 1/2 years old. and he never got prostate cancer!
                    • Yes. There is a difference between WILL get prostate cancer, and increased risk of prostate cancer. I'm sure those who commented were also misinformed.
                      • [quote1299700608=gsicard] I disagree - the vets job is to administer whatever is best for your dog based on an ailment or prescribed treatment. It is not their job to control breeding or suggest spay and neuter. They are to discharge their profession by taking care of the animal that is brought to them. It is the owner who must decide if they want to spay or neuter their dog. Like I said, if a vet ever suggest it to me - they have lost me as a client. That is just how I see things and is in now way a representation of anyone else opinion. I will not surrender my free exercise of pet ownership to a pawn of the industry. I do respect vets and one of my best friends is indeed a vet. However, when I take a dog to the vet it is my money that is being spent - so that is where there influence ends. If they feel so strongly about spay / neuter they should do it for free. :) [/quote1299700608] Well said! When someone comes up to me and sees my intact dog and suggest that I spay or neuter the dog for health reasons...since I didn't ask them...I ask them if they would like to reduce their own chances of getting such cancers and if so if they would be willing to have the same procedure. Of course they always look at me as if I am out of line or crazy. I prevent issues with good nutrition and exercise, but I don't treat (alter a dog) for a condition that doesn't exist. Should a dog GET a cancer that is influenced by the gonads/sex organs, then it may be time for a "fix it" job. As far as the pet over-population problem goes...I will take any dog I produce back and believe all breeders should be willing to do so. It is our responsibility IMO.
                        • [quote1299708990=gsicard] I disagree - the vets job is to administer whatever is best for your dog based on an ailment or prescribed treatment. It is not their job to control breeding or suggest spay and neuter. They are to discharge their profession by taking care of the animal that is brought to them.[/quote1299708990] Oh, my bad :( Vets have nothing to do with shelters and putting down unwanted dogs, absolutely right. !teeth Many vets are also looking for money. I know of some bad vets that will even perform operations that they're not proficient at. Spay and neuter is sort of a "bread and butter" operation. In big cities like Toronto, it is the norm to "fix" dogs at 6mths. It was rare to see intact dogs walking around unless they were under a year old. Vets often assume that spay and neuter is part and parcel of dog ownership. I'm saying don't knock them for asking once, they may forget and ask again, anymore than that and it's badgering. Can't throw away an otherwise decent vet just because he or she asks about it. You guys are harsh! sheesh :S
                          • What is the best time to spay your dog? Can you spay your dog as early as 5months?
                            • Depends on your school pf thought. Read the link I posted.
                              • Someone is having trouble posting to this topic. Does anyone else have that problem?
                                • I've tried every which way to post to this one and cannot :( http://molosserdogs.com/e107_plugins/forum/forum_viewtopic.php?15244
                                  • Man, this is going to drive me insane. My new puppy weighs less than 2 pounds at 8 weeks. I am petrified to have anything done on her. Bernie is not fixed but peanut is so I dont see how Bernie can knock her up. I can see her driving Bernie insane when she is in heat, but because she is so tiny I want to make sure I do it when it is the right time. I see the pros and cons but when dealing with such a small animal what do you think would be the best time ? Peanut was fixed at 8 months and he has incontinence :( he also became a little pudgy even though he doesnt eat that much. So I don't want to ruin her....
                                    • Such a small dog, she may even come into heat as early as 5 months or so. maybe wait till after that, but will have to keep her separate from Bernie. He will be a pain in the buttocks, but there's a chance if he tries anything with her, she might get crushed.
                                      • he has been around a tiny chi in heat before he just foams out the mouth like crazy and liked her lol funny thing is I kept laying him down and the little chi kept backing it up into him what a hooch lol
                                        • I'm really confused. What is the right thing then?
                                          Login or Join to comment.

                                          Castanha
                                          • 2862 views

                                          Partaken

                                          The Campeiro Bulldog
                                          Feeding a Raw Diet
                                          Pics of fila X apbt
                                          why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
                                          American Bully
                                          question about socialization with a fila
                                          Am I Asking For Too Much...?
                                          Serbian defense dog