• 627

Stone Age Dogs and Men

"P.S. Glad you clarified the status on your girlfriend's heritage, but would she have been from a tribal primitive village, it would not have bothered me a bit."

 

Yeah I know and I don't think less of primitive tribal villagers either but I just thought in my girlfriend's case it would be disrespectful to her to make out like she was a primitive tribal villager given her accomplishments, she's much more educated and civilised than me.  Lol. But she's not far removed from tribal people. Her mother was a simple tribal village girl that was adopted by christian missionaries as a teenager, and her father's father was a legendary tribal chief. She still has many many relatives that live exactly as people did 40 000 years ago. Which I think is pretty cool. She herself has extensive wilderness knowledge passed on to her from her mother, and when walking the dogs with her in the wilderness she can find all sorts of food where I only see weeds. She's also a great vegetable gardener. 
Compliments me and my dogs perfectly I think Laughing

 

That's cool about your dad. I'm almost as interested in humans as I am canines, and I'm fascinated by different cultures around the world.

 

 

"Anyway, when exploring the outdoors having a dog on your side that understands you without speaking a word, is a great feeling for me personally. Don't think I'm crazy ok...lol"
Not at all, I know exactly what you're talking about and I imagine it was appreciating this feeling that made you ponder this question. It has caused me to think about similar things.

Replies (5)

    • Sometimes, I wonder how men used to communicate with their dogs during the stone age days? I like to think that their were very little if no language/commands used, as apparently men did not speak words in those days. Having said that, the question is how did their dogs that were used as hunting and protecting companions understand their role?

      • Interesting topic castanha. The history of dog/human relationships and the cultures they were fostered in is my main area of interest.

         

        I don't think it needs to be as much of a mystery as it might seem at first either. In the same way David Attenborough will teach us about natural history by using living examples of animals around today, you can do the same with dog/human relationships. There are living examples that represent an era in history, since it is then that the animal or culture you're seeing arose and it has stayed basically the same since. You look at a jellyfish and you are looking back in time, very far back, to what some of the earliest multicelled organisms were like. They are an ancient design that has stayed basically the same as it worked for them. 
        Similarly you can find human cultures around the world that will be adequate representatives of nearly any era, and you can look at their relationship with their dogs to see what the human/dog relationship was like back when that culture arose. Sometimes JUST the dog/human relationship you're seeing is ancient and it has re-emerged in a newer different culture.

         

        But with what you're talking about, the stone age, you can really see the whole picture quite nicely when you look at the tribal cultures of the highlands in papua new guinea, or really any tribal culture but new guinea has good examples of truly isolated cultures. Also they date back perfectly to just around the time dogs were starting to domesticate themselves (note I didn't say to when man domesticated dogs, cause that isn't how it happened, as indeed tribal PNG shows) and you can see that earliest dog/man relationship.

         

        Now I would just say I don't think man ever, at any point in his history as homo sapiens, let alone since dogs have been around, has not had spoken language. I think even some ancestors of man had language, but man did certainly speak less, and used more whistles and sounds to communicate if you go back to around 40-20 000 years ago. Further back to some of the tribal cultures in africa that are older still than the png tribes and you get those languages that include a lot of clicking sounds within the language, but they still had language and also they pre-date dogs anyway. PNG is really the perfect representative of when dogs first started living with humans. It would have been that melanesian type of tribal people living in asia (40 000 years ago asia was populated by melanesian/australoid type people, not asians) that dogs first sidled up to.

         

        What you'll see in PNG is a very loose relationship between man and dog. The dogs are totally free and wild friends of the people. The people don't necessarily feed the dogs, not consistently, they don't consider it their responsibility. A lady might take pleasure out of feeding dogs or pups and even decide to do it every day but generally the dogs are responsible for feeding themselves and generally looking after themselves. They've simply adapted to living around human encampments, scavenging food (usually not even meat, but rather primitive types of potato and banana, the people don't even get meat regularly) and, apologies in advance, but human feces forms a significant portion of the dogs' diets as well.

         

        Of course, when the men do hunt for meat the dogs are tagging along. On hunts such as this the people wouldn't even speak to one another, let alone to the dogs, because staying quiet is of utmost importance. All communication would be hand signals and body language, with whistles and noises used as necessary. Basically dogs learned to understand fast because those who didn't and blew the hunt in some way would have felt an extremely frustrated wrath from the people. Luckily canids have always been the type to communicate mostly through body language so they picked it up pretty easily.

         

        As a matter of interest my partner is from PNG(having my baby next week!), and her family do use whistles and noises far more than any white people I know. I have some indigenous australian cousins (aunt married an aborigine man) and they're the same (australian aboriginal tribes another great example of the beginnings of the dog/human relationship but it's harder to find aboriginal australians living in their traditional way).

         

        My partner's extended family have a specific whistle (as I've been told every family does), just 3 certain notes in succession, that they'll use to let each other know they're coming or to get their attention in a crowd or whatever. My girlfriend has explained that back in PNG they'll use that whistle to call in their dogs and pigs as well. Like the dogs and pigs of a certain tribe will know their tribes whistle. Lol. They also use a sort of kissing sound to discreetly get each other's attention. And yes I've noticed generally that a lot goes unsaid in their culture as well.

         

        I think this would have suited dogs very much in those earliest days of the dog/human relationship. Perhaps if people were always as yappy as they are now the connection could never have been made.


        A lot of people I know talk to their dogs a lot, use a lot of actual language, but I don't do this and don't really agree with it. For me it's all about body language and noises and whistles. Ofcourse we all know "sick em", and for me that's really shortened to just a sharp "ssu" sound, and it seems every dog quickly learns what that means. I wouldn't be surprised if stone age man used a similar sound, indeed one that has endured time and been passed on from generation to generation for thousands of years, the chinese whisper effect simply landing on "sick em" today.

         

        ps; Just for the record my gf isn't some primitive tribal villager I went and found, she's actually an australian citizen and highschool teacher with a master's degree in linguistics. Her father was the chief of police in a city so yeah, just thought I'd straighten that out. Lol. Still a lot of the primitive stuff remains in their culture, and they all have their connections to the true primitive "stone age " tribes.

        • Wow, you do seem to have great interest in the subject! Glad I posted the question!

           

          I do talk to my dog at home, or when we play, etc..., but when we are outdoors in mountains where there is no human life for hours, I really love the peacefull silence all around and usually remain silent for 8 - 10 hours straight. I used to do that a lot with my other dog, but with my current girl, I will start this winter as I was waiting for the temperatures to cool off before venturing in the wild. (trying to avaoid rattlers) Can't wait to see how she'll behave when no word/command is given for such long time.

           

          Interesting you mentioned the whistling, because I do use whistling a lot more than commands, and strangely enough, it is the same whistle my father used with his dogs...lol  My father came from North African, and his father was from a North African tribe from the mountains. They also used dogs for daily work and hunting, since at the time (about 100 years ago), North Africa still had lions, leopards, cheetas, ect... I am pretty sure there was not much talking going on during that time.

           

          Anyway, when exploring the outdoors having a dog on your side that understands you without speaking a word, is a great feeling for me personally. Don't think I'm crazy ok...lol

           

          Hey, congrats about the new to be born baby. You are a luck man!

           

          P.S. Glad you clarified the status on your girlfriend's heritage, but would she have been from a tribal primitve village, it would not have bothered me a bit.

           

          Good day. 

          • "P.S. Glad you clarified the status on your girlfriend's heritage, but would she have been from a tribal primitive village, it would not have bothered me a bit."

             

            Yeah I know and I don't think less of primitive tribal villagers either but I just thought in my girlfriend's case it would be disrespectful to her to make out like she was a primitive tribal villager given her accomplishments, she's much more educated and civilised than me.  Lol. But she's not far removed from tribal people. Her mother was a simple tribal village girl that was adopted by christian missionaries as a teenager, and her father's father was a legendary tribal chief. She still has many many relatives that live exactly as people did 40 000 years ago. Which I think is pretty cool. She herself has extensive wilderness knowledge passed on to her from her mother, and when walking the dogs with her in the wilderness she can find all sorts of food where I only see weeds. She's also a great vegetable gardener. 
            Compliments me and my dogs perfectly I think Laughing

             

            That's cool about your dad. I'm almost as interested in humans as I am canines, and I'm fascinated by different cultures around the world.

             

             

            "Anyway, when exploring the outdoors having a dog on your side that understands you without speaking a word, is a great feeling for me personally. Don't think I'm crazy ok...lol"
            Not at all, I know exactly what you're talking about and I imagine it was appreciating this feeling that made you ponder this question. It has caused me to think about similar things.

            • Having grew up with bird dogs I can say that it came naturally for them, no words needed to have birds flushed in your face.

              I'm sure even back in the stone ages they would find and keep certain wolves that shown specific traits they needed for hunting and guarding. Which in all reality gave us our dogs today.

              Now I have mastiffs and even with them I have specific dogs that show attributes towards tracking others therapy, but with most both mentioned would be laughable to train them towards. I love to hike with my pack out on our property up north, honestly I use little words while out and about because...Well, it's just not needed.

              Login or Join to comment.

              Castanha
              • 2867 views

              Partaken

              The Campeiro Bulldog
              Feeding a Raw Diet
              Pics of fila X apbt
              why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
              American Bully
              question about socialization with a fila
              Am I Asking For Too Much...?
              Serbian defense dog