UPDATED The Meleager (Calydonian Hunting Dog)
What a great name for a breed, I think it suits the objectives you are setting out to achieve with this new breed of dog. Secondly I wish you good luck.
Yes definately, I, like many others I assume, would love to be kept informed of your progress. So yes please let me know.
Regards,
Neil.
-
- · boomslang
- ·
I am currently in the early stages of a new breed development. As you all well know this is no speedy process but I would like to fill everone in on my efforts thus far. The planning has been about 2 years in the making after finally aquiring a foundation Bitch and willing participants. I am setting out to create A dog with fantastic looks, and still retain superior functionability. a highly stable and trustworthy animal is my ultimate goal. The dog should appear intimidating so as to provide a visual deterent. while never displaying indescriminant agression towads a human or domestic animal (animals the dog has been raised with). It should be totaly trustworthy at all times. With its intentions always apparent. I am not using any Game lines in my breeding program. My foundation bitch does have a very strong prey drive. I have chosen the name Meleager for this breed after the most famous killer of Boar The dogs Appearance should be like that of the animal standing at Meleagers Side in many sculptures. I welcome any questions and suggestions. I will however not disclose my planned formula at this time. Anyone interested in involvment in the development of this breed feel free to email me. There is a set vision for the end result of this breed that I feel can be achieved. Click link below. file:///U:/My%20Pictures/meleager_400.jpg http://homepage.mac.com/cparada/GML/000Images/mim/meleager2127.jpg NEW PICS-The Meleager Website is www.geocities.com/boomslang76/meleagerdog.html -
- · unknown
- ·
What a great name for a breed, I think it suits the objectives you are setting out to achieve with this new breed of dog. Secondly I wish you good luck. Yes definately, I, like many others I assume, would love to be kept informed of your progress. So yes please let me know. Regards, Neil. -
- · Astibus
- ·
boomslang, I will start with that I respect your wish not to disclose the "formula" for your new breed at this time. So, I can't really ask what the dog will ultimately look like in your vision; even though this would really interest me. :) But please allow me to ask you at least, why you perceive the need to create yet another breed? How would your dogs differ substantially from all the others to justify such a program? Don't get me wrong, I'm not opposed to the idea, I just believe that in this day and age, you'd need very good reason to incarnate an entirely new dog permutation. So what is it that you don't find sufficient in any of the other breeds? :) Dan -
- · boomslang
- ·
Thank you for asking Dan, as well as for your interest. I find that while perfectly suitable for some I have yet to find or own a breed that would fit my Ideal description of the perfect dog. I know that no animal can be "perfect " however I do feel that one can be created without the negative attributes that make so many breeds undesireable, or unfeasable for most of us today to own ie Indescriminant agression, poor hips, very short lifespans. I know examples of each of these attributes can be found in different representatives of different breeds however I can assure you what I am striving to create will definatley fill its designated niche. The looks that I hope to acheive should be similar to the very early Dosas, Which look quite simmilar to the Calydonian Dogs. -
- · unknown
- ·
Which breeds exactly have u used? I would really enjoy photos! -
- · unknown
- ·
Interesting. I have a few questions: 1) What were your specific criteria for choosing each component breed and selecting representatives from each breed? 2) How difficult was it to acquire breeding stock that meets your criteria and did you have to make any compromises? A lot in the creation of a breed depends on the quality of the foundation stock, and it is my impression that many top breeders would be reluctant to sell to someone who wants to create a new breed. 3) How much research have you done on your foundation dogs' pedigrees? 4) How many unrelated individuals will comprise your foundation stock? 5) Since behaviour characteristics are high on your list of breeding goals, what behaviour/temperament tests did you use in your selection of breeding stock (and will be using further down in your breeding program)? And are you in consultation with any protection trainers or behaviourists? 6) What tests do you do for inherited diseases? -
- · boomslang
- ·
Again thank you all for your interest. without disclosing too much information I will tell you protection is not a high priority on my list. The dogs are to be companion / working dogs as the name implies. My foundation bitch is 1/4 american bulldog 1/4 English 50% Pit Bull she has an extremely high prey drive. The end result should be a healthy animal. I do research all foundation animals health/ temperment as to the sources of the participants,again I will not disclose at this time. I will tell you that show animals are not sought after for breeding. I am trying to breed the best animals to the best. as a result the appearance could change quite a bit. I have a general Idea of the appearance but I chose to let time and nature sculpt this animal. The end result should be very close what I am striving to accomplish. -
- · unknown
- ·
Oh man, another cross bred (add name here) dog. Like the world doesn't have enough of these already. When is this destructive fad going to stop? I can just see how someone would get really good stock for a "project" like this. The breed "creator" picks his "component" breed and contacts known breeders of those quality dogs: New Breed Creator: "Hello, I am very interested in your dogs." Breeder: "Great, what can I do for you?" New Breed Creator: " You see, I want to create my own breed of super canine. I plan on breeding one of your ----------- to my ---------- ." Breeder: "Go @#&% yourself!" CLICK. Now, the question remains. Does new bred creator lie to get his superior breeding stock, or does he get them wherever he can get them? The paper, BYB's, Brokers, Pet Stores? Seeing how we have tons of already established pure breed dogs with KNOWN histories, KNOW temperments, KNOWN genetic defects it seems very unadvised at best to through all of that to the wind and come up with something were everything is an UNKNOWN. Sounds like a recipe for more dogs ending up in shelters. Enough of this. -
- · boomslang
- ·
Thank you for your comment. I respect your position on this. I would like to respond by letting you know that I in no way have decieved, nor do I intend to decieve any breeded in order to accomplish my goal. This is why the process is so lenghthy and difficult, Im not creating a designer breed I am re-creating a breed that has became extinct, or evolved beyond recocnition. I will tell you I have been treated quite nicely by everyone I have spoken to on this subject , I believe that if you treat others with respect they will return that gesture to you. I would also like to add that, I do not see my animals in shelters I see them in the homes of those that I have chosen to be lucky enough to own such an animal. However, One can only hope for the best no one can see into the future. Im sure the creators of the Akita Inu would not be pleased at the fates that so many of their dogs have suffered. Quality breeding stock will be plentiful because the majority of the animals that I am using are from Working lines "Hunting Dogs" which are as a whole very healthy animals. Very few working dogs have genetic health disorders. Yes the history of genetic defects in Akitas, is unfortunately very well known. The overall breed health of working dogs is due in part to the practices those who breed, and use these dogs adhere to. Using only animals with proven fuctionability, not breeding for conformation. Best of luck to you and thank you for your input. Lane A. -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote=boomslang]Thank you for your comment. I respect your position on this. I would like to respond by letting you know that I in no way have decieved, nor do I intend to decieve any breeded in order to accomplish my goal. This is why the process is so lenghthy and difficult, Im not creating a designer breed I am re-creating a breed that has became extinct, or evolved beyond recocnition. I will tell you I have been treated quite nicely by everyone I have spoken to on this subject , I believe that if you treat others with respect they will return that gesture to you. I would also like to add that, I do not see my animals in shelters I see them in the homes of those that I have chosen to be lucky enough to own such an animal. However, One can only hope for the best no one can see into the future. Im sure the creators of the Akita Inu would not be pleased at the fates that so many of their dogs have suffered. Quality breeding stock will be plentiful because the majority of the animals that I am using are from Working lines "Hunting Dogs" which are as a whole very healthy animals. Very few working dogs have genetic health disorders. Yes the history of genetic defects in Akitas, is unfortunately very well known. The overall breed health of working dogs is due in part to the practices those who breed, and use these dogs adhere to. Using only animals with proven fuctionability, not breeding for conformation. Best of luck to you and thank you for your input. Lane A.[/quote] First of all, you are attempting to "recreate" something you have never actually seen. Aside from a statue or painting or two you have no idea what these priginal animals were like. Chances are, if they went exinct, there was a reason. Secondly, you make very broad based assumptions as to the health of dogs. Genetic defects happen in all dogs, pure breeds and mutts, working, show, hopscotching , all dogs. The differance will be I know what to look out for in Akita-Inu, you will have no idea, and niether will your puppy buyers. Good for you hat breeders have been so receptive to you crossbreeding. Why don't you do everyone a favor and let us know who those breeders are? I am sure that the rest of thier piers would love to know who disregards the history and welfare of thier breed. Ciao, Brad -
- · Astibus
- ·
[quote=JuraiAkitas]Chances are, if they went exinct, there was a reason. [/quote]Empirically speaking, most likely it happens either due to ignorance or war. :wink: [quote=JuraiAkitas]Genetic defects happen in all dogs, pure breeds and mutts, working, show, hopscotching , all dogs.[/quote]That is true, but they accumulate at different rates in show dogs versus working lines. The likelihood of getting a healthy dog is higher, if it is from working lines - that's just plain common sense. JuraiAkitas, even if you are strictly opposed to this idea, you should give people the benefit of the doubt. All modern breeds eventually started out by a vision of someone. If there is a niche for a Meleager, more power to boomslang. I personally devote my time to the preservation of an existing rare breed of ancient times, but that doesn't mean that the efforts of others aren't perhaps equally justifiable. Dan -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote=Astibus"][quote="JuraiAkitas]Chances are, if they went exinct, there was a reason. [/quote]Empirically speaking, most likely it happens either due to ignorance or war. :wink: [quote=JuraiAkitas]Genetic defects happen in all dogs, pure breeds and mutts, working, show, hopscotching , all dogs.[/quote]That is true, but they accumulate at different rates in show dogs versus working lines. The likelihood of getting a healthy dog is higher, if it is from working lines - that's just plain common sense. JuraiAkitas, even if you are strictly opposed to this idea, you should give people the benefit of the doubt. All modern breeds eventually started out by a vision of someone. If there is a niche for a Meleager, more power to boomslang. I personally devote my time to the preservation of an existing rare breed of ancient times, but that doesn't mean that the efforts of others aren't perhaps equally justifiable. Dan[/quote] Dan, I don't believe for one second that you will get a healthier dog because you get one from"working lines." If totally depends on the breeder (if they really acre that much about health and know how to breed away from problems.) and to a large extent, pure luck. I am sure plenty of working GSD come down with VKH,PRA etc. Racing Greyhounds (it doesn't get any more working than that) are notorious for thier PRA problem. It happens. No one is going to breed the "inster breed name here ------) ultimate "genetic defect" free breed. Just won't happen. We have tons of these "recreations" flooding shelters. It's the latest thing, create your very own dog breed. Sorry, I am sick of this trend and I see in no way how it benefits the dog fancy in the long term. -
- · Astibus
- ·
[quote=JuraiAkitas]I don't believe for one second that you will get a healthier dog because you get one from"working lines."[/quote]You may have noticed that I intentionally was talking about likelihood. So no, you will not automatically get a healthier dog from "working lines", but you increase your likelihood of getting a healthy dog. There's a difference. :wink: [blockquote]I am sure plenty of working GSD come down with VKH,PRA etc.[/blockquote]Actually, the GSD is a prime example. If you compared East-German working lines (which historically didn't emphasize looks that much) to say AKC-show lines, you couldn't possibly get a more extreme difference in likelihood for getting a healthy pup. But you are right, many hereditary diseases are somewhat breed specific. In particular recessive traits (e.g. PRA) can have a high prevalence in a particular "gene pool" and can therefore cause problems for the entire breed. Interestingly enough, that you have chosen to mention the Uveodermatologic Syndrome (VKH) in this context. :wink: I don't think that anybody claims to get the "ultimate genetic defect free breed". That, I agree, just won't happen. However, the occurance of genetic defects can be reduced (or increased) based on the selection of a breeding stock - certainly in combination with appropriate breeding. [blockquote]We have tons of these "recreations" flooding shelters.[/blockquote]I think the problem is really, that we have tons of dogs flooding shelters, whether recreations, mutts or pure breds. If you read my very first post to this subject, you will realize that I specifically stated "that in this day and age, you'd need very good reason to incarnate an entirely new dog permutation." So I am with you that nobody needs more dogs in shelters. But for now, I'd be willing to give boomsland the benefit of the doubt that he has a clear vision. Perhaps. :) Dan -
- · boomslang
- ·
Dan you are very kind. In response to the statement of disclosing contributers names, I will not. I can tell you that both of my foundation bitches were already cross breeds. The outcrossings that are to be done will only be to male dogs. therefore no polution to any contributers gene pools could possibly occure. Respectfully Lane A. -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote=Astibus"][quote="JuraiAkitas]I don't believe for one second that you will get a healthier dog because you get one from"working lines."[/quote]You may have noticed that I intentionally was talking about likelihood. So no, you will not automatically get a healthier dog from "working lines", but you increase your likelihood of getting a healthy dog. There's a difference. :wink: [blockquote]I am sure plenty of working GSD come down with VKH,PRA etc.[/blockquote]Actually, the GSD is a prime example. If you compared East-German working lines (which historically didn't emphasize looks that much) to say AKC-show lines, you couldn't possibly get a more extreme difference in likelihood for getting a healthy pup. But you are right, many hereditary diseases are somewhat breed specific. In particular recessive traits (e.g. PRA) can have a high prevalence in a particular "gene pool" and can therefore cause problems for the entire breed. Interestingly enough, that you have chosen to mention the Uveodermatologic Syndrome (VKH) in this context. :wink: I don't think that anybody claims to get the "ultimate genetic defect free breed". That, I agree, just won't happen. However, the occurance of genetic defects can be reduced (or increased) based on the selection of a breeding stock - certainly in combination with appropriate breeding. [blockquote]We have tons of these "recreations" flooding shelters.[/blockquote]I think the problem is really, that we have tons of dogs flooding shelters, whether recreations, mutts or pure breds. If you read my very first post to this subject, you will realize that I specifically stated "that in this day and age, you'd need very good reason to incarnate an entirely new dog permutation." So I am with you that nobody needs more dogs in shelters. But for now, I'd be willing to give boomsland the benefit of the doubt that he has a clear vision. Perhaps. :) Dan[/quote] Dan, I like you, you are one of the only people on this board so far I can say that about. You do have to admit likelihood is at best relative. I don't believe the hype that "working dogs" are any healthier than "show dogs" or that "working dog" people have a the better interest of breeds than "show dog" people. Just open any Robb Report or DuPont Registry and you will see tons of "working dog" ads praying on peoples insecurities and selling SCH: III Chzeck or DDR line GSD's to anyone that has a check, or Visa, or AMEX, or Mastercard. "Working dog" people regularly !@#$ things up too. Back to the topic, there is simply no logical reason for the "creation" of another"ancient reconstruction." Never mind the fact that it is impossible to "reconstruct" anything that you have never seen before. It's kind of like "reconstructing" a T-Rex. There are plenty of knock off 1993 Mercedes Benz kit cars out there. Is that what this new classification of "reconstructed breeds" should be called,,,, KIT DOGS? I believe that pure bred dogs deserve better than to be used as parts for Kit Dogs. -
- · boomslang
- ·
When I am refering to working dogs I am refering to Hunting dogs. Animals that perform actual "work". In this day and age anyone who has GSD or Rottie that comes from a working background all label them as working dogs. Lying around a building or home and waiting to bite some malefactor is not my idea of a working dog. These dogs have a working temperment. and are where health is concerned, better than show. However Anyone who thinks that these animals would have to endure the type of physical rigors that a Plott or Cur would endure while at work is living a dream. animals bred for the work that I am describing are in fact head over hocks, more sound as a breed overall. Because there is a real difference between a guard dogs day of work lazing around somewhere hoping someone to bite will show up, and covering miles of inhospitable terrain only to engage in combat with an angry bear or great cat, when they do finally do stop running. an exception to this would be the true flock guardians. It is as dan said common sense. P.S. Nice Ninja suit! -
- · unknown
- ·
[quote=boomslang]When I am refering to working dogs I am refering to Hunting dogs. Animals that perform actual "work". In this day and age anyone who has GSD or Rottie that comes from a working background all label them as working dogs. Lying around a building or home and waiting to bite some malefactor is not my idea of a working dog. These dogs have a working temperment. and are where health is concerned, better than show. However Anyone who thinks that these animals would have to endure the type of physical rigors that a Plott or Cur would endure while at work is living a dream. animals bred for the work that I am describing are in fact head over hocks, more sound as a breed overall. Because there is a real difference between a guard dogs day of work lazing around somewhere hoping someone to bite will show up, and covering miles of inhospitable terrain only to engage in combat with an angry bear or great cat, when they do finally do stop running. an exception to this would be the true flock guardians. It is as dan said common sense. P.S. Nice Ninja suit![/quote] Boomslang, Plenty of breeds already exsist. Plenty of them are dumped in shelters as it is. I just don't see why we need another Kit Dog. You also stated that only pure males would be used in your "program" not females so there is no comprimise of bloodlines. Well, that is all fine and dandy except your breeders are OK with having thier dogs be in the "pedigree" of a mix bred? That to me is not a good breeder. -
- · unknown
- ·
Boomslang: "Because there is a real difference between a guard dogs day of work lazing around somewhere hoping someone to bite will show up" I find this quite reducing. A guard dog is there to protect the property and family. I wish you luck in producing a dog that has the courage to do so under tremendous stress. Second, the manworking titles are very hard to achieve , since it comprehends tracking , obedience ( which in itself puts alot of pressure in the dog ) and protection. If you are not knowledgeable enough about such topics , refrain from commenting them in such bashing tone. It doesnt make you or your dogs look any better. Tiago -
- · boomslang
- ·
Tiago, My reference is to the fact that the work of a guard dog, which by the way I have personaly owned several breeds in this catagory that would qualify as Manstoppers, DO NOT require or possess the same stamina or genetic resiliance of the true hunting dog breeds ie: working Dogos, working Filas, CAO, Any commonly used hound etc. The dogs I refer to arent doing Manwork everyday they are in fact guarding, this is their working day which is more than likely at a residence, where Im sure they dont spend the time doing Manwork unless a man shows up for them to work. They are most likely resting which is what most animals do so as not to expend energy unnecissarily. Hunting dogs spend their working days running miles at a time to locate quarry these dogs are in fact put together better than ANY GSD or the like could ever dream of being, Because the men who have used them DO NOT include the bad ones in their breedings just to attain a certain temperment or physical trait. If you think that any schutzhund, or work like this is a stress for the dogs participating look at what predator or hog dogs do on a regular basis. Look at the work that the flock guardians perform day to day. you should read about the great Tigre to get some idea of what a real "working dog" does when he punches the time clock. I dont have to make my dogs look any better. If all goes as planned they will speak for themselves. -
- · unknown
- ·
I misunderstood you then. It must be the NEGATIVE atmosphere around here lately. Accept my apologies. Tiago :wink: -
- · boomslang
- ·
No prob Tiago, I've noticed that lately as well. thank you for your input I always enjoy your posts. -
- · unknown
- ·
If you mean by "negative atmosphere" someone who doesn't except or reconize the cross bred "kit dog" phenomina as anything healthy for the fancy, that would only be me on here. Perhaps all it takes is for one to speak the obvious truth to make crossbreeders feel uncomfortable. One would like to think so, but i won't hold my breath. -
- · boomslang
- ·
Jurai Your post are always welcome here. I've told you that I respect your views, Just have some humility. No one is here to bash or discredit anyones ideas or efforts. You are a very knowledgeable individual. Were just having some fun with you thats all. -
- · boomslang
- ·
Kahlua is due in late July, Check out the website for new pics! www.geocities.com/boomslang76/meleagerdog.html