• 1297

Is this normal

So...he was afraid to lose his bone and he learned he was right to be afraid! Next time he may be even more fearful and reactive. Less force, more big brain: Take your puppy to obedience school. Work as a team. He must learn to trust your hand, that it always gives. Hand feed him. You'll have to do some trial and error here. Sometimes providing lots of bones all the time reduces stress, sometimes it make it worse. I always "trade up" for something more delicious when teaching pups to give up their stuff. Possession aggression now can be a sign of a weak nerve problem later in my observation. Work consistently in obedience, that really does help improve all aspects of the relationship. This is not "normal" CO behavior though it is common dog behavior.

Replies (14)

    • uuuuuuuu
      • So...he was afraid to lose his bone and he learned he was right to be afraid! Next time he may be even more fearful and reactive. Less force, more big brain: Take your puppy to obedience school. Work as a team. He must learn to trust your hand, that it always gives. Hand feed him. You'll have to do some trial and error here. Sometimes providing lots of bones all the time reduces stress, sometimes it make it worse. I always "trade up" for something more delicious when teaching pups to give up their stuff. Possession aggression now can be a sign of a weak nerve problem later in my observation. Work consistently in obedience, that really does help improve all aspects of the relationship. This is not "normal" CO behavior though it is common dog behavior.
        • That is common behavior as far as I know. You are doing the right thing correcting it. When you feed the pup you should put your hand in the bowl and let him wait for you to remove your hand to eat. The behavior must be corrected. I would tell you how I did it with my four but - don't want to upset the masses.
          • Hand in bowl let it be adding something delicious like cheese. More big brain, less brawn. That's how the old and weak like myself can own the breed.
            • I have always believe its easier to prevent a problem than to fix one... I sit on the floor and hand feed my pup a treat then pet him as he eats it, all the time talking to him, I pet nose muzzle on sides and front paws.. sometimes I hand him a small treat and before he inhales it show him a bigger 1 that way he gets used to me taking stuff and shows no aggression. I let him lick the bone while I hold it , I turn them sideways so he starts to gnaw on it all the while I continue to pet him and I am holding the bone, while he chews on bone I sit with him. Hugo I am dealing with him 1 on 1 if I am correct you have mutiple dogs so that may throw a variable in others may have better methods for your case.
              • [quote=NickD]I have always believe its easier to prevent a problem than to fix one... I sit on the floor and hand feed my pup a treat then pet him as he eats it, all the time talking to him, I pet nose muzzle on sides and front paws.. sometimes I hand him a small treat and before he inhales it show him a bigger 1 that way he gets used to me taking stuff and shows no aggression. I let him lick the bone while I hold it , I turn them sideways so he starts to gnaw on it all the while I continue to pet him and I am holding the bone, while he chews on bone I sit with him. Hugo I am dealing with him 1 on 1 if I am correct you have mutiple dogs so that may throw a variable in others may have better methods for your case.[/quote] A hearty YES to Big Brain methods!
                • That is so interesting Nick. That is how I have always handled my pups from day one. I haven't known anything different, and my dogs are excelent about there feeding behavior.
                  • Hi Hugo.... I think you are doing right to correct him now, this is the momento you need to do it. As Gary wrotte the pup must know you are the one who feed him. And also very interesting what NickD wrote. You just need to be patient with him , make the correction but after that give him love. each day it would be easy for you, as you said, the second day he just left the bone in your hand, you are doing a great job with him. Keep walking as I always say . Sometimes is much better not to give importance to the pleopple they dont know what they are talking about. Right ?
                    • I actually agree quite a bit with Stacey on this. He growled because he thought you were going to take his bone - and you proved him he was right. Next time this happens chances are the reaction will only increase in severity. "Trading up" rarely seems to work with my CO when she has a bone (bones and meat are top priority around here.) I have her sit and wait out of the kitchen, then maybe even do some basic obedience; sits, downs, short recall to heel, etc. Basically she has to do something for me before she gets what she wants. When she has it I will often take it from her, I tell her good girl assuming she doesn't make a big deal out of it. I then tell her to sit and when she does it she immediately gets the bone back. Starting obedience classes will not only get you to work together, but it is also a neutral place to start teaching him a No, leave it, Pfhooey, Drop it, etc. command. Why be more physical than you have to? I recognize that a dog should be corrected for such an action but if you can tell him "No" (or other command) and he will respond to it, it is much better for your relationship overall. If he then understands the command but still growls, you need to correct him harsher. Keep in mind that if you instigate being physical is a way of being in control, you're in for a hell of ride when he grows up. By the way, I'm all for giving harsh physical corrections - IF THEY ARE A LAST RESORT. Some breeds (GSD, Malinuts esp.) sometimes seem to need a hard correction to get the point across to them. COs, even though they can physically deal with the hardest correction you can give them, are not like many of them in the sense that if they feel a correction is unjust, they'll let you know... and you don't want to be on the other end of that.
                      • [quote=Andreita] Sometimes is much better not to give importance to the pleopple they dont know what they are talking about. Right Gary?[/quote] I just hope you are referring to me not knowing what I am talking about when I advise to LEAD whenever possible instead of dominate!!! :P Clearly draws line of distinction in philosophies in the raising of this breed. I have results to show. How about you?
                        • I also agree with most of what Kris and Stacey are saying. Your CO is doing what comes natural to him and what animal behaviorists call "resource guarding". He is protecting something that he likes and is of value to him. Your method punishment in the long term, especially with a CO will likely have the opposite effect and you will have a time bomb on your hands. Some very basic fundamentals of dog training and rasing chldren are: Train your dog with benevolent leadership as much as possible, not dominance. Control the resources that are pleasurable to the dog and you can mostly control and shape the behavior. Within limits, ignore unwanted behaviors and they will go away. Acknowledging unwanted behavior is enabling that behavior and can result in what dog trainers and behaviorists will call inadvertent training. In other words the dog is actually training you to get what it wants. For example the dog comes up to the table while you are eating and begs and whines for food, you feel bad for him and feed him. The dog has just trained you to feed him in that situation. Lastly, corrections in the form of compulsion (punishment) should only be used when the dog understands the behavior and dogs not comply. If the dog does not know what it is being punished for that is fundamentally not fair to the dog and can cause anxiety and develop behavioral problems that may even be dangerous. There is one other thing for you to keep in mind if you ever have a younger puppy that demonstrates resource guarding of food,especially when eating out of a bowl at normal feeding times. When you work benevolently with the puppy and condition and acclimate him to accept people in close proximity when eating as has been discussed above (kudos to NickD), one additional thing that you can do is just take the food away when the puppy growls. I have a Sarplaninac who was VERY protective of food when he was in the 8 to 12 week range. When I would sit with him to acclimate and condition him to people while he was eating he would snarl and snap at me and I would ignore the growling and just pick of the food and walk away. Very quickly the puppy realized if I growl at this guy then I don't eat. The behavior disappeared very quickly. I controlled the resoucre no physical punishment was needed at all. And one other thing that benevolent methods provide when training a dog is developing a relationship of trust with you, building confidence in the dog and the dog's confidence in you. I raised a pure wolf and several high content wolfdogs this way and they had so much trust in me that I could not only put my hand in their food or grab a bone from them and give it back I could also stick my whole head in the bowl while they were eating as well with no aggressive reaction. I never physically or emotionally punished them so they had no reason to react aggressively with me.
                          • And one other thing that benevolent methods provide when training a dog is developing a relationship of trust with you, building confidence in the dog and the dog's confidence in you. Treu.Inar was very agressive towards my husband when he had a bone.In the beginning he didnt trusted him.Now we are all fit together and build up the trust we can all take away everything from him without agressive behaviour .No punishment only patient and building trust. One rule in my house what you have given you dont take back anyway.
                            • curb this attitude at this stage itself! if my puppy had done that, i'd have reprimanded him sternly n sent him away and after he goes away, i'd have made him come (on command) and i'd have made him sit and then i'd have handed over even tastier treats and made him take them from my hand. always make your dog wait and then eat the food on your command. and do train him by positive re-enforcement techniques and let the bond between you and your puppy grow better and better in training sessions and let the bond between you and your puppy be based only on trust,love and joy! in order to achieve this, you should see to it that obedience sessions don't bore him and you must see to it that he would enjoy more than you! let it be short and entertaining. let it be like an interesting game or his quest for treats and rewards and affection! saying 'NO' is good, but avoid physical contact. make him move away somehow by words itself. just let him know that it is highly unacceptable! he should understand that you cannot be challenged and whatever you do is for his well being. for that trust to take place, obedience sessions between you and your dog is absolutely necessary! i don't suggest you to ask some one else to train him for you. animals respond very well to true love! when your training becomes intense, you'll feel like feeling him and vice versa! you just try it! you should understand him first and then train him with full concentration and focus and intense love! rule out reprimands and negative things. but use 'NO' rarely to correct him. best of luck! hope you'd get the best results!
                              • I have 4 neos and one is a real pain when I give him a bone. I can give all in the same room a bone each and they are quite happy to chew their own bone but this one will try to take from another even if he hasnt finished his one. I collect all the bones (other 3 arent worried) and then slowly one by one give them back wih lots of encouragement and patting. I leave him until the end, he is very clever and watches this and waits patiently for his bone. He is the same with food aswell and I have had him from birth. We have learnt to either feed him away from the others and once he has finished he will sit by my side and not go to the others to steal from them, before he would attack any of the others and we spent a lot of time showing him his food and telling him no to going for the others food. Hard work in the beginning but over time he is slowly coming round. I tried putting him in a kennel and he climbs over 6'6" fence to get out once he has finished and lays by my side. He has never challanged me over food but Im with the dog 24/7 and lots of control is needed to get this dog to listen. I have found him the hardest dog to deal with ever
                                Login or Join to comment.

                                Hugo
                                •  ·  Standard
                                • K

                                  M

                                  1

                                  13 friends
                                • 6 followers
                                • 9193 views

                                Partaken

                                The Campeiro Bulldog
                                Feeding a Raw Diet
                                Pics of fila X apbt
                                why do dobermans seem weak?!?!?!
                                American Bully
                                question about socialization with a fila
                                Am I Asking For Too Much...?
                                Serbian defense dog