Do you think NA ruins dog breeds?

That is an excellent question for which there is not easy answer.  Some of the dogs that enter North America are brought here specifically for their working abilities and are not usually see out in public.  The danger of the breed (dogs) changing and being ruined is when they have a "breed club" or other organization that tries to get them into the American Kennel Club which is a death knell for dog breeds. Breeders of AKC breeds do it for a variety of reason .. and one of them is for money.  When breeding for money becomes a driving force the breed is doomed to change from their original function.  It is laughable when I watch the Westminster Kennel Club show in New York and listen to the announcer proudly state the reason the dogs were created and what their functions are supposed to be.  I often wonder - when is the last time a dog from that line did its duty.

So you did ask a great question and I am sure my comment may have offended some - but for the most part - if a breed in North America gets popular and has breed clubs "promoting their preservation and protection" they are doomed.  Now, there are some exceptions where individual breeders do care and keep their dogs working even if they are part of a club.  Those I respect very much.

  • What do you think of this topic? Do you think North America ruins dog breeds as in working ability? Also for new dog breeds and molossers just entering NA what future do you see for them? Do you see their working abilitys getting worse? Or remaining the same? 

    • That is an excellent question for which there is not easy answer.  Some of the dogs that enter North America are brought here specifically for their working abilities and are not usually see out in public.  The danger of the breed (dogs) changing and being ruined is when they have a "breed club" or other organization that tries to get them into the American Kennel Club which is a death knell for dog breeds. Breeders of AKC breeds do it for a variety of reason .. and one of them is for money.  When breeding for money becomes a driving force the breed is doomed to change from their original function.  It is laughable when I watch the Westminster Kennel Club show in New York and listen to the announcer proudly state the reason the dogs were created and what their functions are supposed to be.  I often wonder - when is the last time a dog from that line did its duty.

      So you did ask a great question and I am sure my comment may have offended some - but for the most part - if a breed in North America gets popular and has breed clubs "promoting their preservation and protection" they are doomed.  Now, there are some exceptions where individual breeders do care and keep their dogs working even if they are part of a club.  Those I respect very much.

      • I agree.

        Popular Discussions
        •  ·  101
        •  ·  8
        Actually Jess. It is a bit different with dogs.  You see for the most part our current crop of dogs …
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · Sure selecting a breed that was bred for a specific task sure does hedge in your favor. But to do a …
        •  · gsicard
        •  · 
        •  ·  62
        •  ·  16
        these dogs are very nice,but with limited info,and practicly no dogs in my country i cant say much..…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · [quote=Nebulosa"][quote="triff]the blue paul was an old scottish fighting breed, built on old englis…
        •  · admin
        •  · 
        •  ·  56
        •  ·  8
        http://molosserdogs.com/e107_plugins/content/content.php?cat.3341
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · the link to write your story is messed up
        •  · Estrela
        •  · 
        •  ·  42
        •  ·  23
        For anyone interested in feeding a raw diet, there is now a very good resource page at www.rawfeddog…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · The member who posted this text was banned - and the post is depricated.
        •  · gsicard
        •  · 
        •  ·  24
        •  ·  11
        I'm with you on the language....I can cuss as good or better (should I say worse? LOL) than ma…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · I noticed on another website, (don't recall WHICH one), ANYWAY, it was mandatory that you intro…
        •  ·  6098
        This is me walking the three Caucasians we had at the time in Virginia. From your left to right is C…
        •  ·  508
        •  ·  1
        Take a moment to browse of of my favorite websites dedicated to big dogs. BigDogmom
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · There is also this very good article about socialization. check it out https://bigdogmom.com/puppy-s…
        •  · guard_dog
        •  · 
        •  ·  59
        •  ·  2
        If you are not opposed to going to the country of origin we do have a few breeders here. look up sha…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · Hi, Does anyone know of any good Bully Kutta breeders in the US and elsewhere? Thanks.
        •  · cawkazn
        •  · 
        •  ·  50
        •  ·  2
        hey guys, so this video has been floating around the internet. the supposed back story is this man a…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · I would be very surprised if the guy who got bitten is really the owner of the dog!
        •  ·  48
        •  ·  4
        In this article on Mongolia today magazine website, the author lays out the history and future of th…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · I found the article by Filippe Touret and have attached it here if anyone wants to have a look. I ho…
        •  ·  45
        •  ·  4
        http://healthypets.mercola.com/sites/healthypets/archive/2012/04/09/slow-growth-diets-for-giant-bree…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · This quote from the article by Dr. Becker is probably the most important for modern dog owners of br…
        •  ·  42
        •  ·  4
        Nice. Gotta love it when your dog does the job.  Mine routinely gets Racoons - and have cornered som…
        •  · 
        •  · 
        •  · Is soldier still on the hunt?
        •  · 37 friends
        • 4
        3
        1
        New Discussions
        1-12