Resource guarding vs. Actual protection

If we take breeds out of the equation altogether? Looking at a family of pariah dogs and listing traits that would distinguish protectors from defenders or? If breed/type-specific, then we'll have tonnes of fun.
  • I decided to start a thread in order to ask THIS question. I wanted to ask it in the bandog forum THEN I wanted to ask it in a thread that I started originally that was brought back up, Johnson vs. Scot American Bulldog. How can one TRULY know if their dog is a natural protector or resource guarding? It appears to me, and I'm JUST asking so don't jump on me, but it appears that the LGDs, with using their OWN minds as many, say are actually watching over THEIR flock/family versus being protective. Is this so, enlighten me please? I only seek knowledge and I chose LGDs because of the "STORIES" I've heard, LOL. I heard the SAME about ABs that they're great with the family and they're natural protectors YET I hear AND read, PARTICULARLY on other forums, I won't name names but it's one that I'LL NEVER post ON, (COUGH, BDB, COUGH), TOO MANY RUDE know-it-alls, that VERY rarely WILL YOU FIND a dog that's a NATURAL protector, they'd be more inclined to run and protect their OWN ass, LOL. Just looking for info and perhaps a good discussion about resource guarding vs. protection and throw in fear biting. How can you know the difference IF there IS one?
    • If we take breeds out of the equation altogether? Looking at a family of pariah dogs and listing traits that would distinguish protectors from defenders or? If breed/type-specific, then we'll have tonnes of fun.
        • This should be fun, will gather my thoughts(I know its friggin scary) and post something after work and dealing with the herd of hounds at home.
          • "resource guarding vs. protection and throw in fear biting. How can you know the difference IF there IS one?" We will go piece by piece...I don't care which breed frankly to me it doesn't make a bit of difference with regards to the above. Resource Guarding~ whatever the dog Truly wants. For example, you gave the dog a bone. Never trained the dog to allow human interaction while it is enjoying it's bone. Human walks up and goes to grab bone, dog bites human. This is resource guarding, which is very natural for a dog to do. Human Protection~ Owner and dog walk down the street stranger comes out from the shadows and starts arguing with owner. Dog starts barking and growling at stranger, random person goes to grab dog owners arm. Dog leaps up and bites strangers arm who then releases owner. This dog has successfully protected its owner. Fear Biting~Dog and owner walk into a store, four people rush the dog to greet it. No one properly introduces themself to the animal going right in to touch the dog. Owner is not paying attention to the dogs distress signals (Dogs eyes and posture) and allows random strangers to surround the dog. The dog tries to pull away but the owner pushes it butt down and tell fido to stay. Random person bends over dog slings arm around the dogs neck to hug it because it's SO cute, Dog bites persons face to get away from the situation. This dog is fearful and not trusting of owners handling or strangers.
            • Thank you babigirl, that sounds like an EXCELLENT post to ME. From what I've noticed from other people's responses, it wasn't on here that resource guarding is protecting what you think YOU own, including your OWNERS.
              • Hi Acamper, a book for reference with regards to this I would reccomend is, "MINE! - A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO RESOURCE GUARDING IN DOGS". Imo-Resource guarding in its very simplist form can be considered the dog protecting its food. Mastiffs are known for resource guarding or owning an object, which in many ways makes them great for the use of property protection. But to me, when a dog resource guard's there was a step missed by whom ever raised the animal, again that is only because I would clobber a dog in my house that ever did this to say...My 6 year old. I teach my dogs from the earliest age that everything is mine and my families, then after (if they are lucky) they may have it. I may sound "mean" here, but there are reasons for it. I have seen what can happen to a child if a dog is allowed to resource guard. I have also had the call from a puppy buyer needing stitches from a five month old, because it was allowed to resource guard. Your dog will only do...What YOU the owner excepts and allows. But to me, fear based responces are Even more nerve racking...More dangerous and difficult to work with. LOL, which again typically I blame on the owner. Hope this helps!
                • Could I find this on Amazon?
                  • Yes...I believe so. I like it-very easy read over all..
                    • Thanks babigirl, I'll check it out.
                      • By the way I don't think it sounds mean AT ALL you supply the food and the dogs way of being they'd BETTER respect you.
                        Popular Discussions
                        •  ·  101
                        •  ·  8
                        Actually Jess. It is a bit different with dogs.  You see for the most part our current crop of dogs …
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · Sure selecting a breed that was bred for a specific task sure does hedge in your favor. But to do a …
                        •  · gsicard
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  62
                        •  ·  16
                        these dogs are very nice,but with limited info,and practicly no dogs in my country i cant say much..…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · [quote=Nebulosa"][quote="triff]the blue paul was an old scottish fighting breed, built on old englis…
                        •  · admin
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  56
                        •  ·  8
                        http://molosserdogs.com/e107_plugins/content/content.php?cat.3341
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · the link to write your story is messed up
                        •  · Estrela
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  42
                        •  ·  23
                        For anyone interested in feeding a raw diet, there is now a very good resource page at www.rawfeddog…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · The member who posted this text was banned - and the post is depricated.
                        •  · gsicard
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  24
                        •  ·  11
                        I'm with you on the language....I can cuss as good or better (should I say worse? LOL) than ma…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · I noticed on another website, (don't recall WHICH one), ANYWAY, it was mandatory that you intro…
                        •  ·  6098
                        This is me walking the three Caucasians we had at the time in Virginia. From your left to right is C…
                        •  ·  510
                        •  ·  1
                        Take a moment to browse of of my favorite websites dedicated to big dogs. BigDogmom
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · There is also this very good article about socialization. check it out https://bigdogmom.com/puppy-s…
                        •  · guard_dog
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  59
                        •  ·  2
                        If you are not opposed to going to the country of origin we do have a few breeders here. look up sha…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · Hi, Does anyone know of any good Bully Kutta breeders in the US and elsewhere? Thanks.
                        •  · cawkazn
                        •  · 
                        •  ·  50
                        •  ·  2
                        hey guys, so this video has been floating around the internet. the supposed back story is this man a…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · I would be very surprised if the guy who got bitten is really the owner of the dog!
                        •  ·  48
                        •  ·  4
                        In this article on Mongolia today magazine website, the author lays out the history and future of th…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · I found the article by Filippe Touret and have attached it here if anyone wants to have a look. I ho…
                        •  ·  45
                        •  ·  4
                        http://healthypets.mercola.com/sites/healthypets/archive/2012/04/09/slow-growth-diets-for-giant-bree…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · This quote from the article by Dr. Becker is probably the most important for modern dog owners of br…
                        •  ·  42
                        •  ·  4
                        Nice. Gotta love it when your dog does the job.  Mine routinely gets Racoons - and have cornered som…
                        •  · 
                        •  · 
                        •  · Is soldier still on the hunt?
                        •  · 4 friends
                        • 4
                        7
                        5
                        New Discussions
                        1-12